Skip to content

Would Mechs Be Useful

Mecha might actually be useful, just not the the way current Sci-Fi sees them. Nearly all current Sci-Fi that I know of regard large humanoid(ish) machines as warriors, 25-150 ton engines of unadulterated destruction. The big ones are BattleTech, Macross, and Gundam.

This Is How You Build a Fully Functional 9-Foot Mech. Go behind the scenes for a look at how the awesome WIRED mech that ruled Comic-Con …

Bulgarov has been helping out a company called Korea Future Technology on their latest project, which is called METHOD-1: a big, real, …

Why don’t we use mechs?

Motors at each joint might be a way around it, but this solution would require heavy duty motors to support the rest of the body. These motors are comparatively heavy, which would mean there would be a significant amount weight focused at the joints, making the mech that much harder to balance.

What are mechs good for?

No. Mechs make no sense from a combat perspective, because they’re huge targets that offer no appreciable gain. In contemporary combat, if you can be seen, you can be hit, and if you can be hit, you can be killed.

Are mechs practical in real life?

Overall, when compared to conventional military vehicles, bipedal, semi-humanoid mechs are generally ineffective and their only advantage is that they look really cool.

Can mechs be real?

Although fictional mechs come in all shapes and sizes, the widely used hulking, humanoid mech design is the most common in gaming, and in life, as we’ve seen with real life attempts to build the kinds of giant mechs that we love in fiction.

Is it possible to build a giant mech?

While it may be possible to build and pilot a mecha large enough to crush humans, they are likely to be lumbering, unstable, and with very limited range. Building a giant killer robot with many degrees of freedom would break a fundamental rule of engineering: avoid unnecessary complexity!

Are military mechs real?

Combat walkers, or just ’mechs,’ have been a part of science fiction for decades.

Can you buy a mech suit?

Created by Suidobashi Heavy Industries, the robotic project titled “Kuratas,” stands at an impressive 13 feet, weighs in at 4.4-tons, and is completely controlled by a pilot resting inside. Designed by Japanese robot pioneer Kogoro Kurata, the Kuratas mobile mech suit can be yours for a mere $1.35 million.

Is it possible to build a mech suit?

In the past, Japanese researchers and engineers have developed robots that can play games and clean up after you. They have even designed and plan to build an elevator to go to space. Now researchers have developed the first made-to-order full-sized, mobile mech suit.

More Answers On Would Mechs Be Useful

How useful would ’mechs’ be in real life? – Quora

Would mechs controlled by human pilots inside be practical war machines? In special roles, yes, they already are. Combat engineering includes a lot of digging, levelling, bridging, demolition and construction. These are best handled with specialised machines, which have also civilian uses, but are ruggedised for the combat environment.

How practical would mechs be in real life? – Quora

Mechs if we managed to get them to work would be amazing for manual labour, You could get this giant machine to lift tons of weight and do the job of several people with just one person, It would also remove several vehicles from work sites like bulldozers and excavators saving a lot of money for the companies but also reducing jobs by a lot.

Would mechs be useful?

Score: 4.2/5 ( 65 votes) While mechs may be useful for engineering, this is modern warfare. Aside from building bridges, which can be done by less expensive manual labor with only slightly more time elapsed, they do not have practical uses in combat. Legs are vulnerable, and armor is trivial at best. Are Mechs possible in real life?

Advantages of Mechs in modern warfare – Worldbuilding Stack Exchange

While mechs may be useful for engineering, this is modern warfare. Aside from building bridges, which can be done by less expensive manual labor with only slightly more time elapsed, they do not have practical uses in combat. Legs are vulnerable, and armor is trivial at best.

How do we make Mechs useful? : worldbuilding – Reddit

On flat ground, mechs are useless unless they can move faster than a tank. In 3D environments, like urban warfare, mechs are only useful if they can climb and/or jump. If a mech is to be useful, it must have spare parts available to it. They are simply too mechanically complex for extended campaigns with no resupply.

physics – Plausible Reasons for usage of Combat Mecha – Worldbuilding …

The benefits and merits of using mecha are highly dependent on how big these mecha are. Under 9’ Tall At the lowest end of the size scale, you have what is probably better coined powered armour. But mecha this big should be considered, if for no other reason than to illustrate where larger mecha sizes potentially don’t have much use.

Fortnite: 5 Reasons We Hate Mechs (& 5 Reasons We Love Them)

Mechs are incredibly mobile for armored vehicles of death. They can dash forward, leap incredible heights, and are not nearly as sluggish as people imagine they’d be. This wouldn’t be so bad if…

Practicality of Mechs : scifiwriting – reddit

The most practical use of mechs I’ve seen in sci-fi are as industrial machines. Look at the SCVs in StarCraft. They can be used for combat but their primary function is for mining. Then there’s the loader from Aliens. Again, Ripley uses it to fight the queen but its intent was for lifting heavy equipment.

Real-Life Advantages of Mechs in Military Use – Mecha Talk

First off, stating that mecha are “basically more durable soldiers” might not be the best way to describe their best usage upon the battlefield. After all, Powered Armor would fill that niche rather well and potentially more economic to field in terms of finances, resources, and man hours of training.

Should mechs be in regular missions? – General Discussion – Warframe Forums

At level 110 the mechs start to be in danger of being killed constantly. While warframes are fine and dandy until level 150 min to 500. After that it takes constant use of skills healing to stay alive. Mechs are cool and a great thing to have when your leveling a new frame and the stalker shows up. Also a much better archgun deploy.

mechs – useful_english.en-academic.com

Mechs — Statue von Hans van Bentem in Rotterdam im Stil eines Mech Der Mech oder Mecha (von altgriechisch mechos) stellt im Bereich der Science Fiction einen allgemeinen Oberbegriff für heute größtenteils noch fiktive, pilotierte Laufroboter und …

Author Topic: Why Build Artillery ’Mechs? (Read 25919 times)

Mechs are still the most mobile heavy ground vehicle you can deploy, which mean it can get in to position and get out far faster than most artillery vehicles. It’s very much a ’shot and scoot’ platform, the fire support mech. The Karnov Artillery transport, inspired in part by the Spooky Gunship, operates in the similar manner.

Mobile Suit Gundam: The 5 Most Practical Mechs For Combat (& 5 … – CBR

5 PRACTICAL: RGM-89 JEGAN. Long-time Gundam fans know the Jegan is a great mobile suit. It’s based on the original RGM-79 mobile suit, but rather than being developed by the Earth Federation Forces, it’s instead made by Anaheim Electronics, an organization known for building some of the most powerful mobile suits in the Universal Century …

Light Mechs worthless? :: BATTLETECH General Discussions

Light mechs are useful to those who are good at making them useful. Some people just cant do it and thats fine. People can beat Dark Souls using a guitar hero controller. Just because its possible, doesn’t mean its good. Its tottaly possible to beat dozens of games in ways that the devs didn’t intend and that the game is not balanced for but thats the problem. Fatbill is saying the game is …

FWL mechs – BattleTech

Those are certainly all FWL-produced mechs from that era. Your backstory would involve being highly connected and rich, because the metaplot of the time is that most Mechwarriors were driving 300-year-old machines and just coming out of a technological dark age. So to have 100% new, high-tech mechs is nearly unheard of.

BattleTech mechs: tips for constructing the best build | PCGamesN

BattleTech Mech Builds. Because of the way BattleTech works, there is no ideal guide for ’Mech building. BattleTech is a game based on improvisation and adaptation: between finances, biome type …

MWO: Forums – Real Life Mechs?

Posted 01 December 2013 – 11:17 PM. Hey everyone! Mechs as real life weapons have always been an interesting concept to me and I’m constantly doing research and brainstorming on what a practical mech would look like and whether or not they would be practical in the real world. 30 foot tall humanoid mechs are definitely out of the question.

MWO: Forums – Lets Make Mechs Viable!

The mech will use a sensor pod as its head, which is going to be optomechanical. The pod is connected to the pilot’s helmet, and is synched to it, so if a pilot swivels his head, the pod swivels with it too. The helmet should be able to read the pilot’s eye movements if he is trying to look far or close. There should also be auxiliary sensors through out the mech which can project images on …

Guide:Exo Mechs strategies – Calamity Mod Wiki – Fandom

The Exo Mechs fight consists of 7 phases total. Phase 1: The first mech chosen is fought until it reaches 70% health. Phase 2: The first mech chosen disappears and the other two appear. This phase continues until one of the mechs reaches 70% health. Phase 3: The first mech reappears and all three mechs will be present.

Chapter 3567: Useful Spoils | The Mech Touch

Chapter 3567: Useful SpoilsThe Mech Touch. Chapter 3567: Useful Spoils. The Mech Touch. “She’s exaggerating.” Ketis said. “Plenty of those alloys are useful in making stronger armor plating or mech weapons. We just have to gather the right amounts.” Gloriana did not look happy. “That’s the problem here.

Advantages of Mechs in modern warfare – Worldbuilding Stack Exchange

Mechs require a large amount of energy to move at a fast speed, bipedally, to carry their weight. Meanwhile, the same amount of energy, used in a tank, would only need to power circular motion, or in an aircraft, engines – which is much more efficient. While mechs may be useful for engineering, this is modern warfare. Aside from building …

technology – What non-combat uses could mechs have? – Worldbuilding …

Depending on the style of mech, I think its greatest advantages over traditional machinery would probably be in its ability to manipulate objects with precision, and (assuming it has legs), its ability to navigate very irregular terrain. I can see mechs being useful in industries like logging and mining. They’d probably be quite useful for …

Why don’t we use mechs in combat? – Quora

Answer (1 of 4): Because they don’t serve practical purpose that doesn’t come with massive drawbacks. No matter which way you slice it, it boils down to that very simple answer… And the military are not interested with an asset that isn’t practical for use… which the drawback above effectively …

science based – Why would giant mechs use melee weapons …

$begingroup$ Walking mechs are perhaps the most impractical weapons platform of anything having equal prominence in fiction. They are useful only when the terrain is too rough for tanks, enemy air control is too effective for friendly air ops, and the environment is lethal to unprotected infantry.

Would bipedal mechs actually be useful? – Spring RTS Engine

they would be useful were humans are useful on todays battlefields. I served in a mountaineer military unit and we had practically no tank-ish units besides a small one that could be transported via helicopter. if there would be a mech which can carry stronger weaponry and armor while still being as maneuverable as humans in that kind of rough terrain, it would be quite a advantage. Same in …

Ideas to make ’Mechs more useful; post ’em here.

A standing ’Mech, like a human being, may use its center of gravity, hip, leg, and feet actuators to spend 1 MP to jump up and change facing by one to six hexsides. When landing the person piloting that ’Mech must make a PSR with a -4 modifier and a +1 modifier per hexside facing chage. This is useful for a ’Mech that wants to more quickly make facing changes.

how useful would this mech be? : SuperMechs

The official unofficial subreddit for Super Mechs, an online mech fighting game. Press J to jump to the feed. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts

Should mechs be in regular missions? – General Discussion – Warframe Forums

At level 110 the mechs start to be in danger of being killed constantly. While warframes are fine and dandy until level 150 min to 500. After that it takes constant use of skills healing to stay alive. Mechs are cool and a great thing to have when your leveling a new frame and the stalker shows up.

Construction Machinery Industry | Mech-Mind Robotics

Mech-Vision software can complete depalletizing, machine tending, order picking, gluing/spraying, precise locating, etc. through a code-free graphical interface. Equipped with 3D vision, deep learning and other advanced algorithms, it can meet complex and diverse practical needs.

Logistics Industry | Mech-Mind Robotics

Mech-Vision software can complete depalletizing, machine tending, order picking, gluing/spraying, precise locating, etc. through a code-free graphical interface. Equipped with 3D vision, deep learning and other advanced algorithms, it can meet complex and diverse practical needs.

Resource

https://www.quora.com/How-useful-would-%E2%80%98mechs%E2%80%99-be-in-real-life?share=1
https://www.quora.com/How-practical-would-mechs-be-in-real-life?share=1
https://arose.scottexteriors.com/would-mechs-be-useful
https://worldbuilding.stackexchange.com/questions/59271/advantages-of-mechs-in-modern-warfare
https://www.reddit.com/r/worldbuilding/comments/5y3abm/how_do_we_make_mechs_useful/
https://worldbuilding.stackexchange.com/questions/10320/plausible-reasons-for-usage-of-combat-mecha
https://gamerant.com/fortnite-mechs-pros-cons/
https://www.reddit.com/r/scifiwriting/comments/8dkz72/practicality_of_mechs/
https://www.mechatalk.net/viewtopic.php?t=16109
https://forums.warframe.com/topic/1241794-should-mechs-be-in-regular-missions/
https://useful_english.en-academic.com/242425/mechs
https://bg.battletech.com/forums/general-discussion/why-build-artillery-mechs/
https://www.cbr.com/mobile-suit-gundam-best-worst-most-practical-useless-impractical-mechs-combat/
https://steamcommunity.com/app/637090/discussions/0/1642039362998691224/
https://bg.battletech.com/forums/the-successor-states/fwl-mechs/
https://www.pcgamesn.com/battletech/mech-builds-best
https://mwomercs.com/forums/topic/143810-real-life-mechs/
https://mwomercs.com/forums/topic/185905-lets-make-mechs-viable/
https://calamitymod.fandom.com/wiki/Guide:Exo_Mechs_strategies
https://ranobes.net/the-mech-touch-214004/1779509.html
https://worldbuilding.stackexchange.com/questions/59271/advantages-of-mechs-in-modern-warfare
https://worldbuilding.stackexchange.com/questions/210664/what-non-combat-uses-could-mechs-have
https://www.quora.com/Why-dont-we-use-mechs-in-combat?share=1
https://worldbuilding.stackexchange.com/questions/52333/why-would-giant-mechs-use-melee-weapons
https://springrts.com/phpbb/viewtopic.php?t=32797
https://bg.battletech.com/forums/ground-combat/ideas-to-make-’mechs-more-useful-post-’em-here/
https://www.reddit.com/r/SuperMechs/comments/i7pd2s/how_useful_would_this_mech_be/
https://forums.warframe.com/topic/1241794-should-mechs-be-in-regular-missions/
https://www.mech-mind.com/use-cases/construction-machinery/002.html
https://www.mech-mind.com/use-cases/logistics/003.html