Skip to content

Why Is Smokeless Powder Better

There are several advantages of smokeless powder over black powder. First, smokeless powder is about three times as powerful as black powder, which extends its range and allows for small caliber ammo.

The burning rate of smokeless powder increases with increased pressure. Smokeless powder does not detonate like high explosives as it has a controlled rate of burn and differs considerably in its burning characteristics from common “black powder.” Black powder burns at essentially the same rate out in the open (unconfined) as when in a gun.

Smokeless powder does not detonate like high explosives as it has a controlled rate of burn and differs considerably in its burning characteristics from common “black powder.” Black powder burns at essentially the same rate out in the open (unconfined) as when in a gun.

More Answers On Why Is Smokeless Powder Better

Black Powder vs. Smokeless Powder | Comparing Gunpowder Types | Rifle …

There are several advantages of smokeless powder over black powder. First, smokeless powder is about three times as powerful as black powder, which extends its range and allows for small caliber ammo. As a result, a soldier can carry more rounds and does not need to worry much about smoke giving his position away. Cordite and 480 g

Everything Handloaders Need To Know About Smokeless Powder

As we’ve already noted, smokeless powder is an energetic material that can produce very high pressures under the right conditions. Powder also burns at a relatively high temperature. Be sure that you only use smokeless powder for its design application as an ammunition propellant.

Guide to Smokeless Powder – Wideners.com

It meters better, resulting in more accurate loads and can have a greater shelf life compared to other powders. Many ball powders will burn at lower temperatures, which should extend the life of a barrel. Ball powder burns at about 3,200 to 3,300 Fahrenheit, while other powders only reach a max of about 3,400 Fahrenheit.

Smokeless powder – Wikipedia

Smokeless powder is a type of propellant used in firearms and artillery that produces less smoke and less fouling when fired compared to gunpowder (“black powder”). The combustion products are mainly gaseous, compared to around 55% solid products (mostly potassium carbonate, potassium sulfate, and potassium sulfide) for black powder.

The More You Know: Black VS Smokeless Powder

Smokeless Powder reacts at much higher pressures than Black Powder Black Powder byproducts attract water and promote corrosion whereas Smokeless Powder usually includes additives to inhibit corrosion. Black Powder is actually a powder whereas Smokeless Powder is normally pelletized extrusions. The solid wastes from Black Powder makes the smoke.

A Brief History of Firearms: Smokeless Powder – NRA Blog

Another advantage was that smokeless powder produced far less fouling after shots than blackpowder, meaning that more shots could be fired before cleaning, and that powder debris was less likely to clog an action.

Expanding the Smokeless Powder Database – National Institute of Justice

Researchers expanded the National Center for Forensic Science Smokeless Powders Database from 100 to more than 800 entries. December 3, 2017 “Smokeless powder” is the name given to modern gunpowder commonly used in firearms because it produces much less smoke than the black powder it replaced.

Why are there no guns with more effective explosives than … – Quora

Smokeless powder is harder to accidentally ignite and does not release a great deal of smoke. It is also more durable and less likely to be inert if wet. It also has far more power than gunpowder and is far cleaner causing less fowling in the barrel so it does not compromise accuracy as much.

Why is gunpowder not an effective explosive? – Quora

Smokeless powder was a revolutionary step forward in firearms technology because it doesn’t produce the extremely sharp pressure curves that black powder does. And it was only a result of smokeless powder that we ever saw the development of cartridges like the .357 Mag., 44 Mag. and the plethora of monster handgun creat Continue Reading

Powder Shortage Statement – Hodgdon

A: Yes, we continue shipping powder as quickly as possible. In fact, we will ship more powder in 2020 than last year. The real problem behind empty dealer shelves is complicated, but is related to shifting supply and demand challenges. As supply decreased in 2019, demand only increased. No one wants to ship more powder than Hodgdon.

The Basics of Selecting Reloading Powders – Gun Digest

Smokeless powder is quite safe to handle because it is not sensitive to shock. The main caution that must be taken is to keep it from open flame or heat. It will ignite above 400 degrees F. Shelf storage is suitable, preferably on a second floor where temperatures remain most stable.

Smokeless vs. Black powder why? – SASS Wire Forum

Howdy Sam, why BP?? because it’s there Real BP is the one true powder And smokeless is just a passing fad. Plus clean up is so easy and no carbon build up. Best to use a bullet designed for BP with the proper lube. Fill case with enough BP so when you seat the bullet it compresses the powder 1/16″-1/8″, leaving no air space.

What Powder Is the Only Kind That Should Be Used in a Muzzleloader?

Sep 7, 2021The gunpowder we use today on most ammunition cartridges is called smokeless powder. It burns faster and cleaner and is just an overall better propellant than black powder which is the preferred propellant for muzzleloaders.

Smokeless Powder Development History: Transitional Propellants

Oct 19, 2021These propellants reduced powder fouling significantly in tiny bores, but because they are roughly 80 percent blackpowder, they remain corrosive. Firearms required the same cleaning as those fired with regular blackpowder. Still, Lesmok must have shown some serious redeeming qualities if semi-smokeless target loads survived nearly a half-century!

Tips and Tricks – Smokeless – Hodgdon

Tips and Tricks – Smokeless. One advantage to reloading is the ability to adjust the load ballistics. This is especially true with today’s powders. In the past, available reloading powders allowed the velocity of factory ammunition to be obtained. In most cases higher than factory velocity came with the risk of higher pressure.

Smoking Smokeless Powder – Springfield XD Forum

What is happening is the lube from the lead bullet is melting and turning to smoke. As long as you shoot lead there will be some smoke no matter what. The only way to reduce the smoke level to near zero is to go with a moly or jacketed bullet. You can try some other powders and see if they smoke less or not.

Don’t use smokeless powder in your black powder gun.

I’ll concede three things about the BP vs Smokeless debate: 1st – you better know “which” smokeless powders are appropriate for approximating original Black Powder pressures; 2nd it’s obviously much easier to double-charge with smokeless; and 3rd – you better know what you are doing when selecting not just your powder but know that demarcation …

Why not smokeless black powder? – Cast Bullet Forum

As for powder selection, Hodgdon777 is the only powder I can get, and I have had good results with it. It is energetic producing velocities in the high 600s with a charge of 8,5 grains and a 124 grain wadcutter. As I mentioned above, my problem with BP and BP substitutes is the oily smoke (I use Bore Butter over the cornmeal filler).

Why don’t we use something other than gunpowder in a cartridge?

Simply because it works so well. Over the last century and a half it has been perfected and continuously improved. Modern smokeless gunpowder replaced Black Powder as a propellant. Black powder is cantankerous, releases large volumes of smoke and can ignite by static electricity. Modern Smokeless Gunpowder is both reliable and predictable.

The 18 Best Reloading – Powders & Primers reviews in 2022

Hodgdon® Smokeless Powder. Winchester® #209 Primers for Shotshells. CCI® Primers – Per 1000. Federal® Centerfire Primers. IMR Smokeless Powder – Rifle. Winchester® Smokeless Ball Powder. Winchester® #209 777 Primers – 100-Pack. Alliant Powder® Smokeless Powders. IMR Smokeless Powder – Shotshell/Handgun.

fast vs. slow burning powders…question | Sniper’s Hide Forum

On a suggestion from an experienced reloader I swithced to IMR 4007 SSC and at various powder charges on a 140 vld was receiving better groups, 4, 3 shot groups were about .4 better at a 100 yards with all other components similar. The 4007ssc is a considerably faster burning powder than the 4831. It concerns me.

How does humidity affect powder? – ChronoPlotter

Aug 19, 2021Smokeless powder is hygroscopic – that is, it has an affinity for absorbing moisture from the air. Powder can be expected to perform differently if it’s wetter or dryer, which is why precision reloaders have long-recommended storing components at consistent conditions, but little public research has been done to put actual numbers to it.

Best Powder For Pistol Reloading (Updated: July 2022)

Apr 12, 20213 Best Powder for Pistol Reloading (as of May, 2022): 1. Winchester – 231 Smokeless Powder Best Powder for Pistol Reloading – Review. Check Price. at Brownells. Winchester 231 smokeless powder is one of the most popular pistol reloading powders. It has a consistent burn rate, low flash, and a clean burn.

Types of Smokeless Powder | Load Data Article

There are three basic types of smokeless powder: flake, extruded and ball. The names refer to the shapes of the individual particles, which are called granules. (Granule may seem like an odd word. It’s used instead of grain because in the avoirdupois measuring system commonly used by Americans, a grain is a unit of weight, 1/7000th of a pound.)

Loss of Smokeless Powder – AmmoLand.com

That’s why the Montana Shooting Sports Association has crafted a bill for the 2015 Montana legislative session to encourage the production of smokeless powder, primers and brass on a small scale …

Which Gun Caliber Is Superior: The .38 Special or the 9mm?

And because of the higher pressures smokeless powder can generate and its effectiveness as a bullet propellant, the 9mm’s case was developed to be stronger with thicker webbing compared to the .38…

Accuracy: fast burning powder vs slow burning powder

Nov 30, 2021Nov 30, 2021. #1. Fast vs slow burning powder and its effect on rife accuracy. It is well known that for a given case capacity/bullet weight/caliber there is an optimum powder charge/powder burning rate/powder density that would maximize the MV potential of a given rifle. However, let us focus on the effect of the fast vs slow powder on rifle …

Powder or Cartridge – Which Came First? – Handloader Magazine

Smokeless powder was not too far away. In 1883, French chemist Paul Vieille was the first to successfully produce a gelatinized nitrocellulose that became smokeless powder. By 1885 the powder, called Powder B, was in production, and by 1886 the French had a new rifle, the 1886 Lebel, and the first smokeless powder cartridge, the 8mm Lebel.

Everything Handloaders Need To Know About Smokeless Powder

Smokeless powders are also described by their composition, grain shape and size, how they’re sold and used. Powder Composition. The typical way we describe smokeless powder in the United States is by referring to how many major compounds it contains—one, two or three. Single-base powder has one primary energetic constituent—nitrocellulose.

A Brief History of Firearms: Smokeless Powder – NRA Blog

Smokeless powder, as the name implies, had the military advantage of not generating a cloud of smoke when fired. Blackpowder smoke would reveal a shooter’s position visually and, after a few rounds, develop a haze that could begin to obscure his vision. Another advantage was that smokeless powder produced far less fouling after shots than …

Resource

https://www.starlinebrass.com/articles/black-powder-vs-smokeless-powder-comparing-gunpowder-types/
https://www.ssusa.org/content/everything-handloaders-need-to-know-about-smokeless-powder/
https://www.wideners.com/smokeless-powder-guide
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Smokeless_powder
https://www.thefirearmblog.com/blog/2016/11/02/black-vs-smokeless-powder/
https://www.nrablog.com/articles/2016/6/a-brief-history-of-firearms-smokeless-powder/
https://nij.ojp.gov/topics/articles/expanding-smokeless-powder-database
https://www.quora.com/Why-are-there-no-guns-with-more-effective-explosives-than-gunpowder?share=1
https://www.quora.com/Why-is-gunpowder-not-an-effective-explosive?share=1
https://hodgdon.com/powder-shortage-statement/
https://gundigest.com/more/how-to/the-basics-of-powder-selection-for-reloaders
https://forums.sassnet.com/index.php?/topic/179976-smokeless-vs-black-powder-why/
https://yestactical.com/what-powder-is-the-only-kind-that-should-be-used-in-a-muzzleloader
https://www.shootingtimes.com/editorial/transitional-propellants/453097
https://hodgdon.com/resources/how-to/tips-and-tricks-smokeless/
https://www.xdtalk.com/threads/smoking-smokeless-powder.42259/
https://www.thefirearmsforum.com/threads/dont-use-smokeless-powder-in-your-black-powder-gun.143121/
https://forum.castbulletassoc.org/thread/why-not-smokeless-black-powder/
https://thegunclub.quora.com/Is-there-something-better-than-gunpowder-to-use-in-a-cartridge?share=1
https://outdoorclip.com/the-18-best-reloading-powders-primers-reviews/
https://www.snipershide.com/shooting/threads/fast-vs-slow-burning-powders-question.15037/
https://chronoplotter.com/2021/08/19/how-does-humidity-affect-powder/
https://cleangunguide.com/best-powder-for-pistol-reloading/
https://loaddata.com/Article/BenchTopics/Types-of-Smokeless-Powder/12
https://www.ammoland.com/2015/03/loss-of-smokeless-powder-the-greatest-threat-to-the-right-to-keep-bear-arms/
https://nationalinterest.org/blog/buzz/which-gun-caliber-superior-38-special-or-9mm-107721
https://forum.accurateshooter.com/threads/accuracy-fast-burning-powder-vs-slow-burning-powder.4051669/
https://www.handloadermagazine.com/powder-or-cartridge-which-came-first
https://www.ssusa.org/content/everything-handloaders-need-to-know-about-smokeless-powder/
https://www.nrablog.com/articles/2016/6/a-brief-history-of-firearms-smokeless-powder/