French tanks were not so much technologically superior to german tanks, they were just designed for a different idea of tank combat. The French tanks such as the B1 were designed to work as individual fighting forces and therefore designed to withstand greater amounts of fire.
At the start of the war, the Soviets and the French both had better tanks than the Germans, however, the Germans had much better army doctrines, their armies were better led, and they had much better tactics. During the course of the war, the Germans built better and better tanks while the Allies improved their army doctrines and tactics.
The T-34 medium tank was a great all-round tank being cheap and simple to produce and being reliable and effective on the battlefield. The Panzer IV was a German medium tank and was the most numerous German tank of World War Two with 8,553 tanks produced. It was one of the few tanks to be produced during the full length of the war.
The French military was larger — on paper — and technologically superior to its German enemy. Testifying to the French advantage is the Somua S35, a plump, cute tank which was one of the best tanks in the world in 1940. Hundreds went into action in May 1940, but to little avail.
Did the Germans have better tanks?
The German Tiger tank (above) had a more powerful main gun, heavier armor, and wider tracks than the American Sherman tank (below). The German 88 is more powerful than any American tank gun used during the course of most of the war.
Which country had the best tanks in ww2?
T-34 – This medium Soviet tank was in production from 1940 thru 1958. Though later tanks produced during this time period proved to have better armor and armament, the T-34 is often recognized as the most effective, highly influential and efficient tank design of WWII.
Did France have good tanks?
In armour and firepower, French tanks were generally not inferior to their German counterparts. In one incident, a single Char B1 “Eure” was able to destroy thirteen German tanks within a few minutes in Stonne on 16 May 1940, all of them Panzer III and Panzer IV tanks.
Were German tanks reliable?
The Germans started the war with good, reliable tanks, and guns that were often slightly underpowered. But due to the demands of the battlefield, later in the war they often rushed production of heavier tanks with a load of mechanical problems.
Did Germany have better tanks in ww2?
American tanks in World War II were generally inferior to their German counterparts. German tanks boasted better armor protection and more firepower.
What made German tanks so effective?
It had sloped armor which increased the effective relative thickness of the armor from 80 mm (3.1 in) to roughly 140 mm (5.5 in), effectively making the front of the tank virtually impervious to enemy fire.
Were German tanks the best in ww2?
American tanks in World War II were generally inferior to their German counterparts. German tanks boasted better armor protection and more firepower. But armor and lethality don’t tell the whole story. The same American tanks were superior to their rivals in other important ways.
What advantages did American built Sherman tanks have over German panzers?
But the Sherman did have some advantages. Its thinner armor made it lighter and more maneuverable on solid ground, an important advantage in the cold, hilly terrain and small villages of Western Europe.
Why didn’t the US have better tanks in ww2?
However, the US didn’t use many heavy tanks for a few reasons. US tank doctrine in WWII emphasized that American tanks should avoid fighting enemy tanks. Killing enemy tanks would be left to anti-tank units, equipped with AT guns and purpose-built tank destroyers.
How bad were American tanks in ww2?
American tanks in World War II were generally inferior to their German counterparts. German tanks boasted better armor protection and more firepower. But armor and lethality don’t tell the whole story. The same American tanks were superior to their rivals in other important ways.
Why was the Sherman tank so bad?
Because of their insufficient armor, the insides of Sherman tanks were prone to catching fire during combat. This problem was compounded when fires ignited shells and other munitions inside a tank.
Did the US have a heavy tank in WWII?
Near the end of the war, the M26 Pershing tank was deployed as the first operational heavy tank of the US Army. It was designated a heavy tank when it was designed in WWII due to its 90 mm gun, which was at the time the largest caliber gun found on a US tank.
More Answers On Were german tanks better than french
Is it true France had better tanks than Germany during WW2?
Yes some of the French tanks were indeed better than the German Panzer mk I & II, however the Panzer mk III & IV were generally a better tank, where the German Panzer divisions excelled was with better communications between the crew, other tanks and battle command. Combined with air support were able to annihilate the French armoured divisions.
Were French tanks better than German tanks? – Quora
French tanks were decent and in some cases exceptional designs, that were being used by officers who didn’t know what to do with them. In fact, the consensus- even from the Germans -doesn’t support the narrative that French tanks by themselves were inferior in comparison to those of the Wehrmacht and SS, not in 1940. Just some quick context below.
France Had a Tank That Could Have Crushed Hitler’s Best (But Was Wasted …
The fall of France in 1940, one of the 20th century’s most consequential disasters, wasn’t supposed to have happened. The French military was larger — on paper — and technologically superior to its…
How Did America’s Sherman Tank Win against Superior German Tanks in …
May 21, 2021German tanks boasted better armor protection and more firepower. But armor and lethality don’t tell the whole story. The same American tanks were superior to their rivals in other important ways….
5 Best German Tanks Of World War Two (And 5 Allied Tanks That Were Even …
May 14, 2021At the start of the war, the Soviets and the French both had better tanks than the Germans, however, the Germans had much better army doctrines, their armies were better led, and they had much better tactics. During the course of the war, the Germans built better and better tanks while the Allies improved their army doctrines and tactics.
Allied historians admit: Germans were by far the best soldiers in WWII …
German machine-guns, mortars, machine-pistols, antitank weapons and armored personnel carriers were all superior to those of Britain and America. Above all, Germany possessed better tanks.” / 10 Throughout the war, the German soldiers’ performance remained unequaled. “…
Did the USSR have better tanks than Germany in WW2?
They were physically bigger than Soviet designs not just heavier. They had more working space, carried superior optics, more ammunition, and better protection. According to Dr S. Hart and Dr R. Hart German Tanks of World War II 1998 Brown Books, late model Panther was best tank of WW2, and as a result Germans had better tanks. Share
Why the Germans Never Beat This French Tank
Jan 19, 2022Why the Germans Never Beat This French Tank In five days, three B1s defending the bridges at Rethel knocked out 20 German tanks, nine armored cars and 38 motor vehicles. by Sebastien Roblin Here’s…
France vs Germany | Comparison military strength
French and German armed forces comparison. Here you can compare military power of countries … Tanks: 406: 328: Armoured fighting vehicles: 6,463: 3,874: Total artillery: 134: 401: Self-propelled artillery: 109: 121: … they were the only one without possessing its own nuclear arsenal. The tests were conducted on the terrains of Sahara Desert.
Tanks of France – Wikipedia
Infantry Tanks (Chars) Light Tanks (Chars Légers), generally similar to other nations’ light tanks, though they were intended to be used more for infantry support rather than scouting, and as such were better armoured but slower than many other light tanks.The Renault R 35 was the most common type; small numbers of the futuristic FCM 36 were built. . The R 35 was also exported to several …
world war two – History Stack Exchange
Another consideration is that the German armour doctrine included speed as a major consideration. French tanks were heavier and consequently slower. This is pretty much in line with the French expectation of fighting a defensive war along the Maginot line. The German doctrine was an evolution of the stormtrooper tactics used in the 1918 offensive.
Tanks in the German Army – Wikipedia
The Panzer 38 had a crew of four and carried a Czech 37mm gun (with 90 rounds) and two machine guns, one coaxial and one in the front (with 2550 rounds). 1400 tanks were produced for the German army in 1939-1942 and many variants used its chassis, including the Hetzer, a tank destroyer with a 75mm gun. Panzer 35 (t) in France, 1940.
WW2 French tanks – Tank Encyclopedia
French limitations in design French tanks were generally better protected than their German opponents. The reasons behind was their doctrine of use. They were not seen as independent units, but spread among infantry units for close support on the battlefield.
Did the Germans really have the best tanks? We’re German German …
Nov 5, 2021When the French Army had small units of better tanks vs larger numbers of inferior German tanks the French tanks lost. When German tanks in 1941 were confonted by well trained Soviet crews using the T-34 and KV-1 they were devestated. Unfortunately for the Soviet’s that wasn’t always the case.
Panther vs Sherman — Which WWII Tank Was Better? – Firearms News
Aug 4, 2020That fact is wielded like a cudgel by those who support the Sherman as the better tank. The Germans on the other hand, had to have a more focused design towards a more singular task, killing other tanks. German tanks couldn’t match their opposites numerically, so they had to be more effective tank killers. This the Panther did very well.
Comparative Tank Repair 101- Were British Tanks More Reliable Than …
The Churchill was one of the heaviest Allied tanks in the war. It had good armor and an excellent chassis that gave it good off road capability. It was roughly equivalent to the Panzer IV in the German army, though it was still only mediocre compared to super tanks like the Tiger. Churchill Mark IV with a 75mm gun German Tanks
WWII -Did the French have better tanks than the Germans?
WWII -Did the French have better tanks than the Germans? – posted in The Barracks: Considering France wasnt really France for at least half the war, Id say no.
France’s Leclerc Super-Tank: Better than American or Russian Armor?
The Leclerc. By the 1970s, the French army knew its AMX-30s could not reliably defeat the latest Soviet tanks such as the T-72. The independent-minded French didn’t want to simply buy new tanks …
Which Was Better: The Sherman Tank or Russia’s T-34?
Nov 26, 2020The Sherman and Cromwell tanks were protected by up to three inches of armor, with lower degrees of protection on the sides and rear. The lighter 1941-model T-34 had only 45 to 60 millimeters of …
How did German tank designs stack up against British/French designs in …
The PzIII was probably the best tank the germans had in a tank vs tank situation. It had a 37 mm gun, similar to the Pz 38 (t), but had more armour, although not alot, 30mm. It had a 3 man turret and a top speed of 40 km/h. The Pz IV was worse in the tank vs tank role, but not because it was a bad tank.
French And British Tanks Changed The Face Of … – WAR HISTORY ONLINE
The effect of the tanks on that first occasion was underwhelming. They were deployed in unsuitable circumstances and without the use of tactics. Even at Cambrai, the Germans saw the limitation of tanks. General von Walter brought field artillery close to the front, trained his gunners to hit moving targets, and took out 11 British tanks.
The Super Simple Reason Nazi Germany Crushed France During World War II
Prior to May 1940, the combined French and British forces had almost one thousand more tanks than the Germans, and French tanks had better armor and more powerful main guns.
Did the Germans really have the best tanks? We’re German German …
When the French Army had small units of better tanks vs larger numbers of inferior German tanks the French tanks lost. When German tanks in 1941 were confonted by well trained Soviet crews using the T-34 and KV-1 they were devestated. Unfortunately for the Soviet’s that wasn’t always the case.
The reasons behind France’s defeat by Nazi Germany in WW2
Concentrating on stopping another German invasion into French territory, Paris had formed a military policy giving importance to the defensive. … Before May 1940, the combined British and French forces had close to 1,000 more tanks than the Germans, French tanks were better armored and had powerful main guns. France was also renowned as the …
Tanks in the German Army – Wikipedia
The Panzer 38 had a crew of four and carried a Czech 37mm gun (with 90 rounds) and two machine guns, one coaxial and one in the front (with 2550 rounds). 1400 tanks were produced for the German army in 1939-1942 and many variants used its chassis, including the Hetzer, a tank destroyer with a 75mm gun. Panzer 35 (t) in France, 1940.
Were German tanks over engineered? – Page 3 – Axis History
German tank units had more tanks with radios. Their radios worked better than those of other countries. German units practised radio communications and trained to operate as a team. In 1940 they faced better armed and armoured French tanks which could barely communicate with each other. A few posts earlier I posted an inaccuracy.
Were German tanks over engineered? – Page 4 – Axis History
The German French actions are examined in The Blitzkrieg Legend: The 1940 Campaign in the West by Karl-Heinz Frieser. … I.e. would a Tiger tank made in the 1930’s be better than the ones made in 1942-44? … German tanks were not overengineered for the most part, if anything their faults is that there was too little final-drive for a given …
Tanks of France – Wikipedia
Infantry Tanks (Chars) Light Tanks (Chars Légers), generally similar to other nations’ light tanks, though they were intended to be used more for infantry support rather than scouting, and as such were better armoured but slower than many other light tanks.The Renault R 35 was the most common type; small numbers of the futuristic FCM 36 were built. . The R 35 was also exported to several …
Did the USSR have better tanks than Germany in WW2?
They were physically bigger than Soviet designs not just heavier. They had more working space, carried superior optics, more ammunition, and better protection. According to Dr S. Hart and Dr R. Hart German Tanks of World War II 1998 Brown Books, late model Panther was best tank of WW2, and as a result Germans had better tanks.
Bouncing Off Bullets: One French Tank Took on Nazi Germany
France will of course go down in history for being defeated by tanks in World War II, but it was not due to lacking tanks—the French army fielded nearly 4,000 tanks of more than a dozen …
Resource
https://www.quora.com/Is-it-true-France-had-better-tanks-than-Germany-during-WW2?share=1
https://www.quora.com/Were-French-tanks-better-than-German-tanks?share=1
https://nationalinterest.org/blog/the-buzz/france-had-tank-could-have-crushed-hitlers-best-was-wasted-19410
https://nationalinterest.org/blog/reboot/how-did-americas-sherman-tank-win-against-superior-german-tanks-world-war-ii-185625
https://www.hotcars.com/ww2-german-tanks-vs-allied-tanks/
https://johndenugent.com/germans-by-far-the-best-troops-in-wwii-even-churchill-admitted-wehrmacht-excellence/
https://skeptics.stackexchange.com/questions/14886/did-the-ussr-have-better-tanks-than-germany-in-ww2
https://nationalinterest.org/blog/reboot/why-germans-never-beat-french-tank-199327
https://armedforces.eu/compare/country_France_vs_Germany
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tanks_of_France
https://history.stackexchange.com/questions/21061/france-vs-germany-in-1940-equipment-vs-organization
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tanks_in_the_German_Army
https://tanks-encyclopedia.com/ww2/france/ww2_french_tanks.php
https://historum.com/threads/did-the-germans-really-have-the-best-tanks-were-german-german-generals-and-tank-crews-really-super-men-but-for-hitler-crews.191115/
https://www.firearmsnews.com/editorial/panther-vs-sherman-which-wwii-tank-was-better/382893
https://www.warhistoryonline.com/world-war-ii/comparative-tank-repair-101.html
http://forum-console.worldoftanks.com/index.php?/topic/134572-wwii-did-the-french-have-better-tanks-than-the-germans/page__st__20
https://nationalinterest.org/blog/the-buzz/frances-leclerc-super-tank-better-american-or-russian-armor-16986
https://nationalinterest.org/blog/reboot/which-was-better-sherman-tank-or-russias-t-34-173354
https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/6reqce/how_did_german_tank_designs_stack_up_against/
https://www.warhistoryonline.com/world-war-i/french-and-british-tanks-changed-the-face-of-warfare.html
https://nationalinterest.org/blog/the-skeptics/the-super-simple-reason-nazi-germany-crushed-france-during-19484
https://historum.com/threads/did-the-germans-really-have-the-best-tanks-were-german-german-generals-and-tank-crews-really-super-men-but-for-hitler-crews.191115/
https://www.warhistoryonline.com/war-articles/the-reasons-behind-frances-defeat-by-nazi-germany-in-ww2.html
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tanks_in_the_German_Army
https://forum.axishistory.com/viewtopic.php?t=229081&start=30
https://forum.axishistory.com/viewtopic.php?t=229081&start=45
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tanks_of_France
https://skeptics.stackexchange.com/questions/14886/did-the-ussr-have-better-tanks-than-germany-in-ww2
https://nationalinterest.org/blog/reboot/bouncing-bullets-one-french-tank-took-nazi-germany-195903