There was a ’Revolution’ in Tudor Government. Discuss this statement with reference to the period 1532 to 1540
This is a contentious historical issue and has been argued about by historians. G R Elton first raised the argument in 1953s and his main arguments for a “revolution in Tudor government were that until the 1530s the government of the country was based upon the Royal Household i.e. the state equated with the King’s private estate.
However, whilst it is true that there was a move towards a fervently dictatorial style of monarchy between 1532 and 1540, this was not revolutionary. Similarly claimed by revisionists such as John Guy and David Starkey, the use of Parliament was not a change in the name of a pre-conceived Revolution, but rather was brought about by necessity.
More Answers On Was There A Tudor Revolution In Government
Tudor revolution in government – summaryplanet.com
This is a contentious historical issue and has been argued about by historians. G R Elton first raised the argument in 1953s and his main arguments for a “revolution in Tudor government were that until the 1530s the government of the country was based upon the Royal Household i.e. the state equated with the King’s private estate.
(PDF) A TUDOR REVOLUTION IN GOVERNMENT | Anna Wang – Academia.edu
Conclusion • There was no revolution, only continuities and changes (which were important). Cromwell did not mastermind a new form of government, rather he made changes in response to events (esp. break with Rome). He had no coherent plan of reform, just lots of ideas.
was there a Tudor Revolution in government? Flashcards | Quizlet
what was the Tudor Revolution in Government? a viewpoint/interpretation of how Cromwell affected the government, Cromwell modernised the government from personal monarchy to bureaucratic government what does Elton argue about revolutions? there was: – a constitutional revolution – a political revolution – a bureaucratic revolution
Was there a Tudor Revolution in Government? by Nicholas Tribe
Cromwell’s reforms were revolutionary because he radically overhauled the government into a series of bureaucratically organised institutions that operated without the danger of an inactive or weak monarch.
Tudor Revolution in Henry Viii – UKEssays.com
However, perhaps this could be interpreted as the Tudor revolution, considering other historic despotic governments, like Communist Russia, although a modern comparison, it was still a revolution of politics and considering politically, socially and economically almost resembled a Medieval state, it does become a fair comparison.
The ’Tudor Revolution in Government’ was the greatest change to England …
The ’Tudor Revoluion in Government’ was the greatest change to England under Henry VIII’s reign. The ’Tudor Revoluion in Government’ was the greatest change to England under Henry VIII’s reign. Disagree: There was a revoluion in the consituion of the country as Henry became head of both the church and the state. This was arguably …
The Tudor Revolution in Government: Administrative Changes in the Reign …
The Tudor Revolution in Government: Administrative Changes in the Reign of Henry VIII G. R Elton 1 Paperback 23 offers from $13.63 Reform and Renewal (The Wiles Lectures) G. R. Elton 3 Paperback $36.95 Get everything you need Page 1 of 1 Start over The War for America, 1775-1783 Piers Mackesy 32 Paperback $23.86
Revolution in Tudor Government Flashcards | Quizlet
Historian G Elton has identified changes that place in the years 1533-1540 as a ’Tudor revolution in Government’. What does he maintain about Thomas Cromwell?
Some Origins of a Tudor Revolution – JSTOR
In that year Elton brought out The Tudor Revolution in Government , resting his thesis, as his subtitle announced, on administrative change.1 ’The Thesis, as we shall call it, was plain. Its essence was that during the 1530s Thomas Cromwell conceived a remodelling of the administrative features of English central government,
To what extent was there a revolution in the government under … – Quora
However, I have actually heard a recorded interview where he says ’when I said there was a Tudor revolution in government, I didn’t mean there was a Tudor revolution in government. What I meant was….’ The traditional view was that everything moved out of the hands of the monarch and into the hands of well trained, intelligent ministers.
Was there a Tudor Revolution in Government? – SlideServe
A Tudor Revolution in government took place in the 1530s. The changes that took place in government were masterminded by Thomas Cromwell , Henry’s chief minister. The main changes according to Elton. Uploaded on May 27, 2012 Adamdaniel + Follow tudor revolution new amounts parliamentary statute law geoffrey elton council royal household royal
There was a ’Revolution’ in Tudor Government. Discuss this statement …
This has all been used by some Traditionalist Historians such as Geoffrey Elton to constitute a claim that there was a Revolution in government at the time of Cromwell’s climb to power. However, whilst it is true that there was a move towards a fervently dictatorial style of monarchy between 1532 and 1540, this was not revolutionary.
Tudor Revolution in Government – Cambridge Core
The study deals with the organs of central government: the financial machinery and the new courts; seals and secretariats and the rise of the secretary of state; the council and the making of the privy council; the royal household and its retirement from national government.
The Tudor Revolution in Government by G.R. Elton – Goodreads
This book is a study of change in the methods and principles of English government in the sixteenth century, from the ’household’ methods of the Middle Ages to the bureaucratic organization of a national monarchy. The most important decade, 1530-40, is given most concentrated attention, but the earlier and later phases …more Get A Copy Amazon
To what extent was government transformed during the reign of … – MyTutor
These factors show that whilst there was undeniably a transformation in government during the reign of Henry VIII, largely brought about the changes brought with the Reformation, there was still continuity and by 1547 much of day-to-day governance across the realm would have remained unchanged. Answered by Mimi T. • History tutor.
Tudor Government | The Historical Journal | Cambridge Core
Starkey’s introduction in the main aims to discredit the notions which over thirty years ago I summed up as a ’Tudor revolution in government’, a purpose which, I think, justifies me in reviewing his theory somewhat thoroughly. Furthermore, Starkey’s sharp and often discourteous tone will, I hope, excuse my inability to take his attack lying down.
Tudor period – Wikipedia
He injected Tudor power into the darker corners of the realm and radically altered the role of the Parliament of England. This transition happened in the 1530s, Elton argued, and must be regarded as part of a planned revolution.
Was the Tudor government completely transformed? – Stuvia
Was the Tudor government completely transformed? Under the reign of Henry VIII the nature and extent of royal authority dramatically changed. Though Elton argues that the series of reforms in government led by Cromwell between 1515 and 1540 were revolutionary, the majority of historians claim that he overstated the reforms of government and …
Thomas Cromwell and Government – History Learning Site
Tudors – Henry VIII – The Reformation However, in recent years, largely as a result of extensive research done by Sir Geoffrey Elton, a new view has emerged – that Thomas Cromwell was a very capable politician who brought in what was termed a ’revolution’ in government.
The Tudor Political System – Britain Express
The Tudor Political System, the full text of A History of the British Nation, by AD Innes. … In that year the revolt of the northern earls was the last futile attempt at coercing government by a baronial insurrection. The depression of the nobility was effected partly by the enforcement of the laws against maintenance and livery through …
Changes in Tudor Government 1509-40: by Steve Walker
Changes in Tudor Government 1509-40: In this revision session we will examine the changes made to the way England was governed and evaluate whether the changes could be considered revolutionary. Focus specimen exam question ’Between the years 1515 and 1540 Tudor government was completely transformed.’
A Reply: Tudor Government: The Facts? – JSTOR
“Tudor revolution in government”’. In so doing, of course, he shifts the ground to territory that he has made peculiarly his own: the historical record. So be it. … Westminster are to be taken as referring to the new palace, unless there is clear indication to the contrary.’0 Thus on 25 January I 550 the council met ’In the Old Palace of …
Henry VIII and government – History Learning Site
The History Learning Site, 16 Mar 2015. 13 Jul 2022. Henry VIII did not have the same approach to government as Henry VII had done. Henry VII was very much a person who wanted to involve himself in the day-to-day running of government – almost in fear that he would lose control of government if he was not in as much control as was possible in …
The Tudor Revolution – Everything2.com
The Tudor Revolution Constitution, parliament & sovereignty. Historians have a propensity for debate, and one is the debate over Professor G. R. Elton’s theory of the Tudor Revolution, something he first expounded in 1953 in his The Tudor Revolution in Government.Professor Elton identifies the 1530s as probably the key decade in the constitutional history of Britain in the sixteenth century …
The Tudor Revolution in Government: Amazon.co.uk: Elton, G. R …
The Tudor Revolution in Government Paperback – 25 Oct. 2010 . by G. R. Elton (Author) 4.0 out of 5 stars 1 rating. See all formats and editions … There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later. Michael Gotthainer. 4.0 out of 5 stars Well written and informative.
Overview: Civil War and Revolution, 1603 – 1714 – BBC
Elizabeth I, the last of the Tudor monarchs, died in 1603 and the thrones of England and Ireland passed to her cousin, James Stuart. Thus James VI of Scotland also became James I of England. The …
The Tudor Political System – Britain Express
The Tudor Political System, the full text of A History of the British Nation, by AD Innes. … In that year the revolt of the northern earls was the last futile attempt at coercing government by a baronial insurrection. The depression of the nobility was effected partly by the enforcement of the laws against maintenance and livery through …
House of Tudor | History, Monarchs, & Facts | Britannica
House of Tudor, an English royal dynasty of Welsh origin, which gave five sovereigns to England: Henry VII (reigned 1485-1509); his son, Henry VIII (1509-47); followed by Henry VIII’s three children, Edward VI (1547-53), Mary I (1553-58), and Elizabeth I (1558-1603). The origins of the Tudors can be traced to the 13th century, but the family’s dynastic fortunes were established …
A-Level History, The Tudors – How far was there a revolution in …
This resource covers as much as A Level students need know about how Henry VII governed England. It includes a lecture, essay plan and quiz. It does not just explore the context, but evaluates how far Henry VII’s government can be considered a ’new monarchy’. It refers to relevant historiography and prepares students for possible A2 questions.
Revolution reassessed : revisions in the history of Tudor government …
Revolution reassessed : revisions in the history of Tudor government and administration … revisions in the history of Tudor government and administration. Publication date 1986 Topics Great Britain — Politics and government — 1485-1603 … There are no reviews yet. Be the first one to write a review. 0 Previews . 1 …
Resource
https://www.summaryplanet.com/history/Tudor-revolution-in-government.html
https://www.academia.edu/5973734/A_TUDOR_REVOLUTION_IN_GOVERNMENT
https://quizlet.com/200722364/was-there-a-tudor-revolution-in-government-flash-cards/
https://prezi.com/hf5i8eawfbx6/was-there-a-tudor-revolution-in-government/
https://www.ukessays.com/essays/history/tudor-revolution-during-the-reign-of-henry-viii-history-essay.php
https://www.studocu.com/in/document/g-d-goenka-university/english-history/the-tudor-revolution-in-government-was-the-greatest-change-to-england-under-henry-viiis-reign/11520179
https://www.amazon.com/Tudor-Revolution-Government-Administrative-Changes/dp/0521092353
https://quizlet.com/5391060/revolution-in-tudor-government-flash-cards/
https://www.jstor.org/stable/41343245
https://www.quora.com/To-what-extent-was-there-a-revolution-in-the-government-under-Henry-VIII?share=1
https://www.slideserve.com/adamdaniel/was-there-a-tudor-revolution-in-government
https://www.mytutor.co.uk/answers/14786/A-Level/History/There-was-a-Revolution-in-Tudor-Government-Discuss-this-statement-with-reference-to-the-period-1532-to-1540/
https://www.cambridge.org/core/books/tudor-revolution-in-government/BD0F05C67FBEA60CAF5EE77CA14D36ED
https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/815122.The_Tudor_Revolution_in_Government
https://www.mytutor.co.uk/answers/22907/A-Level/History/To-what-extent-was-government-transformed-during-the-reign-of-Henry-VIII/
https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/historical-journal/article/abs/tudor-government/40117587DBC3DA77534712B637A7016E
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tudor_period
https://www.stuvia.com/doc/273414/was-the-tudor-government-completely-transformed
https://www.historylearningsite.co.uk/tudor-england/thomas-cromwell-and-government/
https://www.britainexpress.com/History/The-Tudor-Political-System.htm
https://prezi.com/0wa4cictkbei/changes-in-tudor-government-1509-40/
https://www.jstor.org/stable/2639422
https://www.historylearningsite.co.uk/tudor-england/henry-viii-and-government/
https://everything2.com/title/The+Tudor+Revolution
https://www.amazon.co.uk/Tudor-Revolution-Government-Administrative-Changes/dp/0521092353
https://www.bbc.co.uk/history/british/civil_war_revolution/overview_civil_war_revolution_01.shtml
https://www.britainexpress.com/History/The-Tudor-Political-System.htm
https://www.britannica.com/topic/House-of-Tudor
https://www.tes.com/teaching-resource/a-level-history-the-tudors-how-far-was-there-a-revolution-in-government-in-the-reign-of-henry-vii-11519737
https://archive.org/details/revolutionreasse0000unse