Despite his complex character, Montgomery remains one of the best-known generals of the Second World War and one of the British Army’s greatest ever commanders.
Montgomery was a difficult man to like but one impossible to ignore. He was everything the regular British officer disliked; pushing, innovative, lacking the social graces, unintentionally rude; iconoclastic. American officers disliked him because they thought Montgomery was a “typical” British officer.
If I were Montgomery, we wouldn’t still be here,” Field Marshal Erwin Rommel said as the Afrika Korps continued pressing against El Alamein in the late summer of 1942. He believed Montgomery would have withdrawn. Rommel was not given to retreats, yet he had little confidence of defeating the Eighth Army.
The war was not all victories for Montgomery, however. He suffered his worst defeat in battle during his September 1944 attempt to cross the Rhine River at the Dutch city of Arnhem.
The most contentious of command rivalries during World War II involved General George S. Patton, Jr., of the U.S. Army and British Army Field Marshal Bernard L. Montgomery. Their squabbles, in the field and in the press of the day, have been recounted many times in books and on the silver screen.
Why was Montgomery disliked?
Montgomery was a difficult man to like but one impossible to ignore. He was everything the regular British officer disliked; pushing, innovative, lacking the social graces, unintentionally rude; iconoclastic. American officers disliked him because they thought Montgomery was a “typical” British officer.
What did Rommel think of Montgomery?
If I were Montgomery, we wouldn’t still be here,” Field Marshal Erwin Rommel said as the Afrika Korps continued pressing against El Alamein in the late summer of 1942. He believed Montgomery would have withdrawn. Rommel was not given to retreats, yet he had little confidence of defeating the Eighth Army.
Did Montgomery like his men?
This is an official photograph showing Lieutenant General Bernard Montgomery in 1942 taking tea in the desert during the North African campaign where he was commander in the Eight Army. Immensely liked by his troops, Montgomery was less popular in Whitehall and with other commanders.
Did Montgomery ever lose a battle?
The war was not all victories for Montgomery, however. He suffered his worst defeat in battle during his September 1944 attempt to cross the Rhine River at the Dutch city of Arnhem.
Did Montgomery and Patton dislike each other?
The most contentious of command rivalries during World War II involved General George S. Patton, Jr., of the U.S. Army and British Army Field Marshal Bernard L. Montgomery. Their squabbles, in the field and in the press of the day, have been recounted many times in books and on the silver screen.
Was Montgomery considered a good general?
Despite his complex character, Montgomery remains one of the best-known generals of the Second World War and one of the British Army’s greatest ever commanders.
Did Patton and Montgomery get along?
The rivalry between General George S. Patton, Jr., and Field Marshal Bernard L. Montgomery became a significant obstacle in Allied cooperation.
What did Churchill say about Montgomery?
On Field Marshall Sir Bernard Montgomery: “Indomitable in retreat, invincible in advance; insufferable in victory.”
Did Patton ever face Rommel?
In real life the two were never involved together in a major confrontation, as Rommel was wounded in 1944 and later forced to commit suicide (due to his association with the anti-Hitler conspirators of the July 20 plot), before Patton had command in large-scale land operations.
What did Erwin Rommel believe in?
One of the most widely debated questions about Erwin Rommel is the extent to which he supported Nazism, and by extension, the Holocaust. Some have argued he was deeply complicit. Others have suggested that, while he supported the Nazis, he did so grudgingly or out of political naiveté.
Did Patton and Montgomery like each other?
The most contentious of command rivalries during World War II involved General George S. Patton, Jr., of the U.S. Army and British Army Field Marshal Bernard L. Montgomery. Their squabbles, in the field and in the press of the day, have been recounted many times in books and on the silver screen.
Was General Montgomery arrogant?
Montgomery was arrogant, unlikeable, but ultimately successful. He famously lacked diplomacy and tact when dealing with others. But this directness made him a great military leader.
Who was the best British soldier in ww2?
Field Marshal Montgomery is a leader who maintained integration with other forces through which he was able to concentrate massive fire power. His integration of operations and command between the Army and Royal Air Force led him to become success leader.
Was Field Marshal Montgomery an effective leader?
The rivalry between General George S. Patton, Jr., and Field Marshal Bernard L. Montgomery became a significant obstacle in Allied cooperation.
Did Patton beat Montgomery?
U.S. General George S. Patton and his 7th Army arrive in Messina several hours before British Field Marshal Bernard L. Montgomery and his 8th Army, winning the unofficial “Race to Messina” and completing the Allied conquest of Sicily.
What did general Bradley think of Patton?
Bradley didn’t like Patton; Bradley even feared Patton. But Bradley had the courage and intelligence to use Patton as no other commander could have or probably would have, and Patton, for his part, hungered to be so used.
More Answers On Was Montgomery A Bad General
What is your evidence that Bernard Montgomery was a bad general?
Answer (1 of 5): The term Bad is too simplistic a term to describe any commander’s abilities unless they are truly terrible. Montgomery had some good even great abilities and some terrible ones. Montgomery was a product of the post WW 1 British army who never really adapted to mechanized warfare….
Top Ten Reasons Field Marshal Montgomery is Not so Great
The Memoirs of Field Marshal Montgomery. Pen & Sword, 2016. The featured image in this article, a photograph of General Bernard L. Montgomery watching his tanks move up in North Africa, November 1942, is a work of a U.S. military or Department of Defense employee, taken or
Why did people think Montgomery was a bad general, esp. in comparison …
Montgomery wasn’t a bad general by any stretch, but he had a bad habit of never admitting he was wrong. When you combine that with the fact that he was a nightmare as a subordinate and not very congenial as a colleague, this tends to affect the historiography. 1. Share. Report Save.
If Montgomery was a bad general, how did he defeat Rommel?
Answer (1 of 30): A bad general? Eisenhower: “General Montgomery is a very able, dynamic, type of army commander”. Eisenhower on D-Day and Normandy: “He got us there and he kept us there” General Günther Blumentritt: “Field Marshal Montgomery was the one general who never suffered a reverse…
Bernard Montgomery – Wikipedia
Field Marshal Bernard Law Montgomery, 1st Viscount Montgomery of Alamein, KG, GCB, DSO, PC, DL (/ m ə n t ˈ ɡ ʌ m ər i … ˈ æ l ə m eɪ n /; 17 November 1887 – 24 March 1976), nicknamed “Monty” and “The Spartan General”, was a senior British Army officer who served in the First World War, the Irish War of Independence and the Second World War. Montgomery first saw action in the …
The Many Mistakes of Bernard Montgomery – WAR HISTORY ONLINE
General Bernard Montgomery was facing incredible danger in the battles following the Normandy landings, as the Allies suffered heavy losses in their mission to continue pushing their way inland. Because the situation was so dire, it was common protocol to engage the enemy from a distance, relying on heavy artillery shelling. Unfortunately, despite his cautious hesitation, Bernard Montgomery …
Monty: World War II’s Most Misunderstood General, Part 1
Montgomery demonstrated the insececurity of a short man at almost every opportunity .While choosing in Africa to build up a public persona , Rommel’s legend is strictly accomplishment based .While seeking out ways to annoy superiors , he demanded unconditional obediance from subordinates .Eisenhower’s task was far above anything a Montgomery could have accomplished because of his …
President Eisenhower’s Top 5 Most Disliked Contemporaries
British General in command of 21st Army Group, W.W. II Many in the Allied command considered Montgomery to be arrogant and self-infatuated, while he viewed himself as the world’s greatest military mind. He resented that Eisenhower was his superior, openly expressing disdain and privately belittling his generalship.
Letters show Monty as ‘repressed gay’ | UK news – the Guardian
Feb 26, 2001One boy was Lucien Treub, Montgomery’s “little Swiss friend”, who met him at 12, and told Hamilton how the general would bathe him personally and rub him down so he would not catch cold.
10 Reasons People Have Called General Douglas MacArthur a “Jerk”
6. Immunity for War Criminals, 1945. MacArthur gave the dreaded Unit 731 members of the Japanese Army immunity from war crimes charges after the war in order to get their research on germ warfare and other human experiment results. These murderous psychopaths escaped justice because of MacArthur’s miscalculation.
The Falaise Gap: Ike vs. Monty and a Failure of Command
The only general in Normandy who could have imposed boundary restrictions on the “northward movement of Bradley’s 12th U.S. Army Group” was General Bernard Law Montgomery. Bradley denied that this ever happened, but De Guingand has a solid reputation for historical accuracy. Stephen Strafford’s Diary
Top 10 Worst Military Leaders in History – Toptenz.net
10. (Tie) Field Marshal Bernard Montgomery, U.K. Okay, not really a bad field commander. In fact, a pretty fair one. … In my defense, I do not maintain that Rommel was a bad General. In fact, considering the circumstances he had to deal with—lack of supplies, harsh conditions, being perpetually outnumbered—he did a remarkable job as …
Who Was the War’s Most Overrated Leader? | HistoryNet
So there we have it. Sixteen world-class historians named 16 different people as the war’s most overrated leader: Guderian, Speer, Hitler, Hirohito, de Gaulle, Zhukov, Stalin, Churchill, Roosevelt, Eisenhower, MacArthur, Clark, Montgomery, Bradley, Patton, and “Bomber” Harris—each received one vote. Given that spread, I’m casting the …
Monty and Patton: Unfriendly Allies – World History
A Personal Battle. The battle between Patton and Montgomery began almost immediately. When a British attack below Catania faltered, Montgomery unilaterally decided to maneuver his XXX Corps around the base of Mount Etna and assault Messina from the west. Monty took over Highway 124, which Lt. Gen. Omar Bradley’s II Corps was using for its …
Bernard Law Montgomery: Unbeatable and unbearable
Field Marshal Bernard Law Montgomery was one of the most prominent and successful British commanders of the Second World War (1939-45). Known as ‘Monty’, he notably commanded the Allies against General Erwin Rommel in North Africa, and in the invasions of Italy and Normandy. View this object. Major Bernard Law Montgomery in 1915.
Montgomery Bus Boycott – Facts, Significance & Rosa Parks – HISTORY
The Montgomery Bus Boycott was a civil rights protest during which African Americans refused to ride city buses in Montgomery, Alabama, to protest segregated seating. The boycott took place from …
The worst military leaders since Napoleon – History 101
British Field Marshal Sir Bernard Montgomery. Britain Field Marshal Sir Bernard Montgomery – If an American is making this list, then you know British General Montgomery is included toward the top. … Even before Operation Barbarossa starting going bad, which was effectively the turning point in the war, Hitler made some seriously poor …
Montgomery and Rommel – Legion Magazine
On Aug. 15, 1942, when Lieutenant-General Bernard Montgomery took command of the British Eighth Army in North Africa, the British forces held a precarious defensive line based on El Alamein, Egypt, a way station 100 kilometres west of Alexandria.If that city fell to Field Marshal Erwin Rommel’s Afrika Korps, the Germans would wrest control of Egypt and potentially the Suez Canal from Britain.
The National Interest: Blog | The National Interest
General Van Ovost Plans to Weaponize Cargo Aircraft by Kris Osborn January 15, 2022. MQ-25a Stingray Drones Can Now Refuel Jet Fighters in Mid-Air by Stephen Silver January 15, 2022.
Bernard Law Montgomery, 1st Viscount Montgomery – Britannica
Following World War II, Montgomery was made a knight of the Garter and was created 1st Viscount Montgomery of Alamein in 1946. He commanded the British Army of the Rhine and served as chief of the Imperial General Staff from 1946 to 1948. He became chairman of the permanent defense organization of the Western European Union (1948-51) and then …
Field Marshal Bernard Montgomery – History Learning Site
Welcome to SirDoggie. Bernard Montgomery was born in 1887. He was educated at St. Paul’s School and Sandhurst and in 1908, aged 21, he gained a commission in the Royal Warwickshire Regiment. During World War One, Montgomery served on the Western Front. A highly efficient young officer, he was given a succession of command posts both in …
Bernard Montgomery, World War II Field Marshal – ThoughtCo
Bernard Montgomery (November 17, 1887-March 24, 1976) was a British soldier who rose through the ranks to become one of the most important military leaders of World War II. Known to be difficult to work with, “Monty” was nevertheless exceptionally popular with the British public. He was rewarded for his service with promotions to Field …
Why General Eisenhower Threatened to Quit Just Before D-Day – HISTORY
Allied Chiefs Air Marshal Arthur Tedder, General Dwight D Eisenhower, and Field Marshall Bernard L. Montgomery, watch tank maneuvers on February 25, 1944 in preparation for the D-Day landings …
Military families live apart because of under … – Montgomery Advertiser
Military families live apart because of under-performing schools, Maxwell general says. During a speech to a group of more than 100 people attending Leadership Montgomery’s Education Summit, Lt …
The National Interest: Blog | The National Interest
by Caleb Larson. Follow @calebmlarson on Twitter. L February 10, 2022.
THE ALLY WE LOVED TO HATE – The New York Times
Mar 11, 1984The general’s papers are an exceedingly rich source, but Mr. Hamilton has confined himself too closely to them and the papers and recollections of men close to Montgomery. The biography rarely …
Village of Montgomery Events
Village of Montgomery 133 Clinton Street Montgomery, NY 12549 (845) 457-9661 (845) 457-5698. Village Hall Hours: 8:30am – 4:30pm. Connect “Images of America: Village of Montgomery”
The worst military leaders since Napoleon – History 101
British Field Marshal Sir Bernard Montgomery. Britain Field Marshal Sir Bernard Montgomery – If an American is making this list, then you know British General Montgomery is included toward the top. … Even before Operation Barbarossa starting going bad, which was effectively the turning point in the war, Hitler made some seriously poor …
September 26, 1944: Market Garden, Montgomery’s Biggest Failure
A Brief History. On September 26, 1944, Operation Market Garden came to an end, failing to take all the objectives and suffering greater losses than the Germans, a fairly unusual occurrence at that point in the war. Normally maddeningly conservative, Field Marshall Bernard Law Montgomery placed his faith in a rapid advance to and across the …
Scandals of Classic Hollywood: The Long Suicide of Montgomery Clift …
Montgomery Clift had the most earnest of faces: big, pleading eyes, a set jaw, and the sort of immaculate side part we haven’t seen since. He played the desperate, the drunken, and the deceived …
Resource
https://www.quora.com/What-is-your-evidence-that-Bernard-Montgomery-was-a-bad-general?share=1
https://www.historyandheadlines.com/top-ten-reasons-field-marshal-montgomery-great/
https://www.reddit.com/r/ShitWehraboosSay/comments/jikemw/why_did_people_think_montgomery_was_a_bad_general/
https://www.quora.com/If-Montgomery-was-a-bad-general-how-did-he-defeat-Rommel?share=1
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bernard_Montgomery
https://www.warhistoryonline.com/war-articles/many-mistakes-bernard-montgomery.html
http://armchairgeneral.com/monty-world-war-iis-most-misunderstood-general.htm
https://www.nps.gov/features/eise/jrranger/5accomp4X.htm
https://www.theguardian.com/uk/2001/feb/26/books.booksnews
https://www.historyandheadlines.com/10-reasons-general-douglas-macarthur-jerk/
https://warfarehistorynetwork.com/2018/12/23/the-falaise-gap-ike-vs-monty-and-a-failure-of-command/
https://www.toptenz.net/top-10-worst-military-leaders-in-history.php
https://www.historynet.com/who-was-the-wars-most-overrated-leader/
https://worldhistory.us/military-history/ww-ii-history/monty-and-patton-unfriendly-allies.php
https://www.nam.ac.uk/explore/bernard-montgomery
https://www.history.com/topics/black-history/montgomery-bus-boycott
https://www.history101.com/worstmilitaryleaders/
https://legionmagazine.com/en/2017/05/montgomery-and-rommel/
https://nationalinterest.org/blog/reboot/george-patton-vs-montgomery-who-was-better-world-war-ii-general-165253
https://www.britannica.com/biography/Bernard-Law-Montgomery-1st-Viscount-Montgomery
https://www.historylearningsite.co.uk/world-war-two/military-commanders-of-world-war-two/field-marshal-bernard-montgomery/
https://www.thoughtco.com/field-marshal-bernard-montgomery-2360162
https://www.history.com/news/eisenhower-churchill-d-day-wwii
https://www.montgomeryadvertiser.com/story/news/education/2018/08/21/bad-schools-hurt-maxwell-air-force-base-general-montgomery-alabama-schools-families-live-apart/1053656002/
https://nationalinterest.org/blog/reboot/allies-and-rivals-why-general-patton-clashed-montgomery-during-world-war-ii-165235
https://www.nytimes.com/1984/03/11/books/the-ally-we-loved-to-hate.html
https://www.villageofmontgomery.org/events/
https://www.history101.com/worstmilitaryleaders/
https://www.historyandheadlines.com/history-september-26-1944-market-garden-montgomerys-biggest-failure/
https://www.vanityfair.com/hollywood/2014/09/scandals-of-classic-hollywood-montgomery-clift