Longstreet and his defenders were not only traitors to the South, willing to accept loss and move on, they had been right about Gettysburg. And Lee, the great symbol of southern nobility, had been wrong.
Longstreet didn’t think the Confederate army should have been so far north at all. He takes a lot of blame for the failure at Gettysburg overall, because it’s said he delayed his actions during the battle.
Before his death, Longstreet told one of his opponents at Gettysburg, Union General Daniel Sickles, that the battle ’was the sorest and saddest reflection of my life for many years. ’ He grieved not for what might have been during those three July days, but what had been — the terrible price that he had foreseen.
Wert concludes that Longstreet was a superb though humanly flawed general. He was certainly the best subordinate commander in Lee’s army and perhaps the best in any army on either side during the Civil War.
Longstreet played a controversial part in the Confederate defeat at the Battle of GettysburgBattle of GettysburgOne of the largest military conflicts in North American history begins on July 1, 1863, when Union and Confederate forces collide at Gettysburg, Pennsylvania. The epic battle lasted three days and resulted in a retreat to Virginia by Robert E. Lee’s Army of Northern Virginia.https://www.history.com › the-battle-of-gettysburg-beginsThe Battle of Gettysburg begins – HISTORY in 1863, in which he reluctantly oversaw “Pickett’s Charge,” a doomed offensive that resulted in a Confederate defeat.
’They lacked the fire and point of his usual bearing on the battlefield. ’ Longstreet allowed his disagreement with Lee’s plans to affect his generalship, and he deserves censure for this. While he may have opposed the idea of an offensive, he was still in a position of responsibility.
by Jeffry Wert Simon and Schuster, $27.50 527 pp. General James Longstreet has always been a question mark in the history of the American Civil WarAmerican Civil WarThe American Civil War (April 12, 1861 – May 9, 1865; also known by other names) was a civil war in the United States between the Union (states that remained loyal to the federal union, or “the North”) and the Confederacy (states that voted to secede, or “the South”).https://en.wikipedia.org › wiki › American_Civil_WarAmerican Civil War – Wikipedia. For years he was blamed by his former Confederate associates for the South’s decisive defeat at the battle of Gettysburg.
Why was Longstreet blamed for Gettysburg?
Longstreet didn’t think the Confederate army should have been so far north at all. He takes a lot of blame for the failure at Gettysburg overall, because it’s said he delayed his actions during the battle.
What did Longstreet say about Gettysburg?
Before his death, Longstreet told one of his opponents at Gettysburg, Union General Daniel Sickles, that the battle ’was the sorest and saddest reflection of my life for many years. ’ He grieved not for what might have been during those three July days, but what had been — the terrible price that he had foreseen.
Was Longstreet a good Confederate?
Wert concludes that Longstreet was a superb though humanly flawed general. He was certainly the best subordinate commander in Lee’s army and perhaps the best in any army on either side during the Civil War.
Did Longstreet fight at Gettysburg?
Longstreet played a controversial part in the Confederate defeat at the Battle of Gettysburg in 1863, in which he reluctantly oversaw “Pickett’s Charge,” a doomed offensive that resulted in a Confederate defeat.
Why did Longstreet disagree with Lee at Gettysburg?
’They lacked the fire and point of his usual bearing on the battlefield. ’ Longstreet allowed his disagreement with Lee’s plans to affect his generalship, and he deserves censure for this. While he may have opposed the idea of an offensive, he was still in a position of responsibility.
Who is blamed for the loss at Gettysburg?
by Jeffry Wert Simon and Schuster, $27.50 527 pp. General James Longstreet has always been a question mark in the history of the American Civil War. For years he was blamed by his former Confederate associates for the South’s decisive defeat at the battle of Gettysburg.
What did James Longstreet do in the Battle of Gettysburg?
Longstreet played a controversial part in the Confederate defeat at the Battle of Gettysburg in 1863, in which he reluctantly oversaw “Pickett’s Charge,” a doomed offensive that resulted in a Confederate defeat.
What did James Longstreet do?
James Longstreet (January 8, 1821 – January 2, 1904) was one of the foremost Confederate generals of the American Civil War and the principal subordinate to General Robert E. Lee, who called him his “Old War Horse”.
What did general Longstreet do at Gettysburg?
Longstreet’s most controversial service was at the Battle of Gettysburg in July 1863, where he openly disagreed with General Lee on the tactics to be employed and reluctantly supervised several unsuccessful attacks on Union forces.
What side was Longstreet?
James Longstreet was a U.S. Army officer, government official and most famously a lieutenant general in the Confederate Army during the Civil War (1861-65). One of Robert E. Lee’s most trusted subordinates, Longstreet played a pivotal role in Confederate operations in both the Eastern and Western Theaters of the war.
Why was Longstreet hated?
When General Lee died in 1870, former associates built Lee up by bashing the perfect foil, Longstreet. False claims that Gettysburg was the turning point of the war, and that Longstreet refused to attack when he had the chance on the second day, made Longstreet the Southerner Southerners loved to hate.
Was Lee and Longstreet friends?
Longstreet took command of the Right Wing (later to become known as the First Corps) and Jackson was given command of the Left Wing. Over time, Lee and Longstreet became good friends and set up headquarters very near each other.
Did Longstreet lose Gettysburg?
For many people who blame Longstreet for the loss (or show outright disdain for the man), it all goes back to the 1863 Battle of Gettysburg — specifically, Pickett’s Charge. It was an attack Longstreet didn’t order or want, but he still takes the blame for its failure.
Why did Longstreet urge Lee not to attack Union forces at Gettysburg?
As it turned out Longstreet was correct and Pickett’s Charge failed and the south never again was able to threaten the North. Lee hoped for a tactical victory destroying the Union Army, Longstreet hoped for a strategic victory by out moving the Union Army.
What does Longstreet say to Lee about the attack?
Longstreet had said precisely that, just hours before the assault, to Lee himself: “General,” he said, “I have been a soldier all my life. I have been with soldiers engaged in fights by couples, by squads, companies, regiments, divisions and armies, and should know, as well as any one, what soldiers can do.
Who is to blame for the Confederate loss at Gettysburg?
General James Longstreet was one of the Confederate army’s most trusted and capable officers. After the Battle of Gettysburg and long after the end of the Civil War, Longstreet takes much of the blame for the southern loss at the battle – and sometimes for the loss of Civil War itself.
More Answers On Was Longstreet Right At Gettysburg
Was Longstreet right at Gettysburg? – Meltingpointathens.com
Was Longstreet right at Gettysburg? Longstreet and his defenders were not only traitors to the South, willing to accept loss and move on, they had been right about Gettysburg. And Lee, the great symbol of southern nobility, had been wrong. Was Longstreet a good general? Wert concludes that Longstreet was a superb though humanly flawed general.
Longstreet at Gettysburg, the Second Day – American Battlefield Trust
Chapter XXVII–Gettysburg–Second Day. The stars were shining brightly on the morning of the 2d when I reported at General Lee’s head-quarters and asked for orders. After a time Generals McLaws and Hood, with their staffs, rode up, and at sunrise their commands filed off the road to the right and rested.The Washington Artillery was with them, and about nine o’clock, after an all-night march …
Gettysburg: Was Longstreet Right about Lee’s Decisions?
There are many reasons for the outcome at Gettysburg, but I believe it all comes down to three factors. First and foremost is that Lee tried to play the forcing game as stated later by E. Porter Alexander, Lees artillery commander. Longstreet being conservative was against it and I believe had a better plan.
America’s Civil War: Robert E. Lee and James Longstreet at Odds at …
Of all Gettysburg’s controversies, none has so shaped history’s interpretation of the battle as has the Lee-Longstreet dispute. The controversy had its origins in the days following Lee’s brilliant victory at Chancellorsville, May 1-5, 1863. In the woods and fields west of Fredericksburg, Va., Lee’s outnumbered army defeated the …
Longstreet – Longstreet was right. – American Civil War Forums
Longstreet was definitely right to argue with R.E. Lee at Gettysburg and Pickett was well within his rights to never forgive Lee for ordering the assault. Last edited: Mar 16, 2021 Reactions: Work in Progress , Booklady , Pete Longstreet and 5 others
Longstreet – Scapegoat or Culprit | HistoryNet
Much recent opinion has absolved Longstreet from blame at Gettysburg. “Now that Longstreet is again being recognized as one of the more heroic Confed-erates…” ran a comment of a leading Southern newspaper. “Old Peter Longstreet was a giant of a man,” said the editor of a prominent magazine of history a short time ago.
When Confederate General James Longstreet Lost the Battle of Gettysburg …
The 1874 act that convinced the writer that Longstreet had lost Gettysburg was his commanding state militia in September of 1874 against the White League coup in New Orleans, … Even Black people will admit that creating a situation under which blacks ruled in governments in the south, right out of slavery, was ridiculous. Reply. admin says:
Was Confederate General James Longstreet responsible for the South’s …
Answer (1 of 27): Not only no, but Hell no. Longstreet’s reputation took a hit from the post-war Lost Causers specifically Jubal Early the former General and editor of the Southern Historical Society. Longstreet had the audacity to promote reconciliation and became a Republican. However, he wasn…
’No man … more honored’: Longstreet’s 1888 Gettysburg visit
And, of course, his criticism of Lee’s soldiering at Gettysburg was an unforgivable sin for many Confederate devotees. Longstreet, who lived in semi-retirement on his farm in Gainesville, Georgia, arrived in Pennsylvania on June 30. On the train ride to Gettysburg, he sat near Gen. Hiram Berdan, whose two regiments of sharpshooters slowed the …
Confederate Commanders at Gettysburg – National Park Service
At Gettysburg his troops arrived in the right place and attacked at the right time, stampeding Union troops through Gettysburg and capturing hundreds. … Col. Edward P. Alexander- In command of a reserve artillery battalion in Longstreet’s Corps, the responsibility of the cannonade prior to Pickett’s Charge on July 3rd was placed on his …
Lee, Longstreet disagreed on 2nd day strategy – Baltimore Sun
The attack that would take place on July 2, 1863, was the source of a disagreement between Lee and Longstreet on the morning of the battle. According to Jeffry Wert in James M. McPherson’s Battle …
James Longstreet – HISTORY
James Longstreet was a U.S. Army officer, government official and most famously a lieutenant general in the Confederate Army during the Civil War (1861-65). One of Robert E. Lee’s most trusted …
In Defense of Lee’s Warhorse: A Review of Longstreet at Gettysburg by …
Pfarr’s mission is to “critically reassess” the Longstreet-at-Gettysburg evidence in order to evaluate whether or not the claims against “Lee’s Warhorse” hold water. … writing in the early-20th century in an effort to right the wrongs done to her husband, quite clearly had an agenda. …
James Longstreet – Wikipedia
James Longstreet (January 8, 1821 – January 2, 1904) was one of the foremost Confederate generals of the American Civil War and the principal subordinate to General Robert E. Lee, who called him his “Old War Horse”.He served under Lee as a corps commander for most of the battles fought by the Army of Northern Virginia in the Eastern Theater, and briefly with Braxton Bragg in the Army of …
Did Longstreet disagree with Lee at Gettysburg? – Quora
Answer (1 of 4): Yes. As has been pointed out, Longstreet wanted to slide to the right (southeast) and establish a new defensive line between the Army of the Potomac and Washington DC, on ground of his and Lee’s choosing. Had they done so, the Army of the Potomac would have had to attack, as Mead…
Longstreet At Gettysburg, The Third Day – Civil War Home
GENERAL LEE has reported of arrangements for the day,–“The general plan was unchanged. Longstreet, reinforced by Pickett’s three brigades, which arrived near the battle-field during the afternoon of the 2d, was ordered to attack the next morning, and General Ewell was ordered to attack the enemy’s right at the same time.
WHY Lee Didn’t Listen To Longstreet… | American Civil War Forum
The history of Gettysburg often says that Longstreet advised Lee not to attack the Federal positions on July 2, and especially not to attack on July 3rd! Longstreet advised Lee to move around the federal right flank, forcing Meade out of position & onto ground more favorable for the Army of Northern Virginia. … He went right after Lee from …
General James Longstreet at Gettysburg. Part III. – Alan E. Hunter
Joshua Chamberlain, Daniel Butterfield, James Longstreet and one-legged Dan Sickles. pose in Gettysburg on July 3, 1888. Sickles lost his leg at Gettysburg on July 3, 1863. After the General died in 1904, his widow Helen Dortch Longstreet, known as the “Fighting Lady,” spent the next half century fulfilling a promise made to her husband …
Gettysburg Battlefield Hike: Longstreet’s July 2nd Attack
After the Confederates failed to gain the high ground south of Gettysburg, Gen. Robert E. Lee began to plan a July 2nd attack on both flanks of the Union Line. Lee’s wanted the Confederates to envelop the Union Army and Lieut. Gen. James Longstreet’s First Corps was responsible for attacking the left flank of the Union line. Longstreet’s July …
Longstreet At Gettysburg, The Second Day – Civil War Home
Longstreet At Gettysburg, The Second Day. The stars were shining brightly on the morning of the 2d when I reported at General Lee’s head-quarters and asked for orders. After a time Generals McLaws and Hood, with their staffs, rode up, and at sunrise their commands filed off the road to the right and rested.
General James Longstreet at Gettysburg. Part II. – Alan E. Hunter
Longstreet’s final years were marked by poor health and partial deafness. By 1902 he suffered from severe rheumatism and was unable to stand for more than a few minutes at a time. By January 1903, his weight dropped from 200 to 135 pounds, cancer developed in his right eye, and he underwent X-ray therapy in Chicago to treat it.
Longstreet at Gettysburg: A Critical Reassessment Paperback – amazon.com
Winner, 2019, Gettysburg Civil War Roundtable’s Distinguished Book Award, best book published on the Gettysburg Campaign This is the first book-length, critical analysis of Lieutenant General James Longstreet’s actions at the Battle of Gettysburg. The author argues that Longstreet’s record has been discredited unfairly, beginning with character assassination by his contemporaries after the war …
Gettysburg 150: Longstreet and Lee and the Quintessential Battle
In Gettysburg, Pennsylvania 150 years ago, 51,000 people died or were severely wounded. … Longstreet is right. You can perhaps bluff an inside straight draw, but you must understand that this is a pure bluff. An inside straight draw is a very weak hand. … The Killer Angels by Michael Shaara is an example of a Civil War book that treats …
The Lee versus Longstreet Battle Strategy Conflict – CliffsNotes
Longstreet was a strong proponent of the tactical defensive in warfare, a good idea in the right situation, such as at Fredericksburg. However, there is no one formula for success. Whereas Lee was constantly adjusting his strategy to accommodate new developments, Longstreet offered no such flexibility. Also, it is a lot harder to be the person …
Longstreet at Gettysburg – American Civil War Message Board
2006-07-05T15:16. Longstreet receives so much blame mainly because of Jubal Early (a division commander in Ewell’s II Corps during Gettysburg). Never a fan of Longstreet, Old Pete’s joining the Republicans after the war and accepting a position with them seems to have raised the ire of his former comrades.
Who Played Longstreet In The Movie Gettysburg – WhatisAny
It features an ensemble cast, including Tom Berenger as James Longstreet, Jeff Daniels as Joshua Chamberlain, Martin Sheen as Robert E. Lee, Stephen Lang as George Pickett, and Sam Elliott as John Buford.It features an ensemble cast, including Tom Berenger as James Longstreet, Jeff Daniels as Joshua ChamberlainJoshua ChamberlainAfter the war, he entered politics as a Republican and served four …
Longstreet at Gettysburg: A Critical Reassessment
This is the first book-length, critical analysis of Lieutenant General James Longstreet’s actions at the Battle of Gettysburg. The author argues that Longstreet’s record has been discredited unfairly, beginning with character assassination by his contemporaries after the war and, persistently, by historians in the decades since.
General James Longstreet monument (Gettysburg) – All You Need to Know …
General James Longstreet monument, Gettysburg: Address, General James Longstreet monument Reviews: 4.5/5. See all things to do. General James Longstreet monument. … He was right. Read more. Written May 5, 2019. This review is the subjective opinion of a Tripadvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC. 1. 2. Showing results 1-10 of 12.
Longstreet’s 1st Corps – The Battle of Gettysburg
James Longstreet. Lieutenant General James Longstreet ( West Point Class of 1842) commanded the 1st Corps at Gettysburg. He was the next senior Confederate officer at Gettysburg to Robert E. Lee. Longstreet had commanded the First Corps since it was established in the fall of 1862. He was the only experienced Confederate corps commander at …
Why one general takes the blame for the South losing at Gettysburg
Longstreet didn’t think the Confederate army should have been so far north at all. He takes a lot of blame for the failure at Gettysburg overall, because it’s said he delayed his actions during the battle. U.S. Army. Whether it was a good idea or not, the last day of the Battle of Gettysburg saw 12,500 Confederate soldiers charged an …
Resource
https://www.meltingpointathens.com/was-longstreet-right-at-gettysburg/
https://www.battlefields.org/learn/articles/longstreet-gettysburg-second-day
https://www.tapatalk.com/groups/thecivilwarhomepagediscussion2824/gettysburg-was-longstreet-right-about-lee-s-decisi-t1208.html
https://www.historynet.com/americas-civil-war-robert-e-lee-and-james-longstreet-at-odds-at-gettysburg/
https://civilwartalk.com/threads/longstreet-was-right.183437/
https://www.historynet.com/longstreet-scapegoat-or-culprit/
https://thereconstructionera.com/when-confederate-general-james-longstreet-lost-the-battle-of-gettysburg-in-1874/
https://www.quora.com/Was-Confederate-General-James-Longstreet-responsible-for-the-South%E2%80%99s-loss-at-Gettysburg?share=1
https://john-banks.blogspot.com/2017/01/no-man-more-honored-longstreets-1888.html
https://www.nps.gov/gett/learn/historyculture/confederate-commanders-at-gettysburg.htm
https://www.baltimoresun.com/news/bs-xpm-2005-06-26-0506160311-story.html
https://www.history.com/topics/american-civil-war/james-longstreet
https://keithharrishistory.com/keith-harris-history/2019/9/16/in-defense-of-lees-warhorse-a-review-of-longstreet-at-gettysburg-by-cory-m-pfarr
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_Longstreet
https://www.quora.com/Did-Longstreet-disagree-with-Lee-at-Gettysburg?share=1
http://www.civilwarhome.com/longstreetgettysburg3.html
https://www.americancivilwarforum.com/why-lee-didnt-listen-to-longstreet…-79594.html
https://alanehunter.com/2018/06/23/general-james-longstreet-at-gettysburg-part-iii/
https://civilwarhikes.blogspot.com/2011/03/gettysburg-battlefield-longstreets-july.html
http://www.civilwarhome.com/longstreetgettysburg2.html
https://alanehunter.com/2018/06/16/general-james-longstreet-at-gettysburg-part-ii/
https://www.amazon.com/Longstreet-at-Gettysburg-Critical-Reassessment/dp/1476674043
https://litkicks.com/GettysburgOne/
https://www.cliffsnotes.com/literature/k/the-killer-angels/critical-essays/the-lee-versus-longstreet-battle-strategy-conflict
https://www.tapatalk.com/groups/thecivilwarhomepagediscussion2824/longstreet-at-gettysburg-t1099.html
http://pricode.eon.airlinemeals.net/content-https-whatisany.com/who-played-longstreet-in-the-movie-gettysburg/
https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/44404448-longstreet-at-gettysburg
https://www.tripadvisor.com/Attraction_Review-g60798-d12617466-Reviews-General_James_Longstreet_monument-Gettysburg_Pennsylvania.html
https://gettysburg.stonesentinels.com/confederate-headquarters/1st-corps/
https://www.wearethemighty.com/articles/why-one-general-takes-the-blame-for-the-south-losing-at-gettysburg/