Skip to content

Was Hamilton The Deciding Vote

Is Alexander Hamilton’s infamous letter to his friend John Jay the basis for the book Was Hamilton The Deciding Vote? The answer may surprise you. While Hamilton was one of the most brilliant public figures of the founding generation, his letter to John Jay was not about the presidency. In fact, it was written to discuss an issue that had come to his attention: how to defeat Jefferson after his election. While he was a lawyer, Hamilton understood the political context and saw that the Federalist Party’s delegates were the ones who needed to vote against Jefferson.

The idea of an Electoral College is not as old-fashioned as it sounds. In fact, the Electoral College idea was introduced just one year before the first election. Hamilton, who had a history of supporting American independence, lobbied to tip the election in his favor. His role was far from prominent; he viewed Jefferson as less of an existential threat. However, Hamilton’s argument is not entirely without merit.

The first tier of the Electoral College was comprised of electors from each state. These electors would serve for life. The second tier would elect the president, who would serve for life, but also enjoy veto power over Congress. Hamilton’s scheme was accepted by Jefferson, whose administration would not challenge it. However, in the thirty-sixth vote, James Bayard abstained, which was crucial to ensuring the success of his plan.

More Answers On Was Hamilton The Deciding Vote

What Was Alexander Hamilton’s Role in Aaron Burr’s … – HISTORY

Hamilton lobbied against Burr, but another federalist cast the deciding vote for Thomas Jefferson. As the presidential election of 1800 approached, Americans were more divided than ever before.

The Election of 1800: Hamilton’s Role – It’s Hamiltime!

In an interesting post-script to the election, Hamilton eventually persuaded fellow Federalists to choose Jefferson over Aaron Burr. Smithsonian Magazine has a great piece explaining the deadlock- because of the system in place, Congress had to decide between Jefferson and his running mate Aaron Burr. Many Federalists saw Jefferson as the ultimate enemy and were pushing for a Burr presidency.

What Hamilton Leaves Out About The Jefferson/Burr 1800 Election

The final vote of the contingent election declared Jefferson the winner and, as Hamilton explained it was indeed a landslide — but it didn’t start that way. There was a high amount of pressure for the House to decide on a Presidential Elect; the new nation was quickly approaching a civil war, and the eyes of the world were on America after the Revolutionary War.

PolitiFact: Fact-checking ’Hamilton’ the musical

The musical’s rivalry between Hamilton and Burr peaks after the election of 1800. Hamilton sways the delegates to elect Jefferson with a late, tie-breaking “endorsement” that lifts Jefferson …

The real-life election of 1800 was even wilder than Hamilton the …

The real-life election of 1800 was even wilder than Hamilton the musical lets on. Thomas Jefferson and Aaron Burr, circa 1800. Much of the climax of Lin-Manuel Miranda’s musical Hamilton hinges on …

Why Alexander Hamilton Never Became President – Biography

Alexander Hamilton was in his early 30s during the debate and passage of the U.S. Constitution and the first presidential election. While Hamilton certainly craved political advancement and fame …

How Much of the Hamilton Musical Is True? – ELLE

The musical portrays Hamilton as singlehandedly dooming Burr’s presidential run in 1800, when he casts a deciding vote in favor of Burr’s opponent, Jefferson. In reality, Hamilton didn’t have that …

The Burr vs. Hamilton duel happened on this day | The National …

3. Hamilton helped make Burr a political exile. After the 1800 election, Hamilton didn’t let the feud with Burr drop. Jefferson also ignored Burr as his vice president, and he made it clear that under new election rules, there was no way Burr was going on the 1804 ticket. Hamilton then worked to defeat Burr’s attempt to become governor of …

Whose Vision of America Won Out—Hamilton’s or Jefferson’s?

Gutzman argues that the debate over the competing visions of Jefferson and Hamilton was settled in the election of 1800. “In the 1790s Hamilton wanted to use the military to tamp down political …

A question about The Election of 1800 : hamiltonmusical

Ohhhh! I always thought that Hamilton was the final deciding delagate so that Jefferson won by a single delegate vote. I thought “you won in a landslide” was sarcastic or political spin (like people saying Trump won in a landslide). This makes a lot more sense that Hamilton was able to convince lots of delegates.

Hamilton on the Electoral College – Oklahoma Council of Public Affairs

Alexander Hamilton wrote of the presidential election system: “it is at least excellent.” … those Electors would meet and actually deliberate before deciding and voting. This is one area where the American Founders were a little shortsighted about human nature. Whether it was legislators appointing Electors, or voters electing them, people …

Hamilton and the U.S. Constitution | American Experience | PBS

Hamilton’s decision to accept Burr’s challenge was a last despairing attempt to stay in politics. It was an attempt that ended in tragedy. …

Alexander Hamilton | The First Amendment Encyclopedia

Hamilton has mixed First Amendment legacy. Hamilton and James Madison were the leading contributors to The Federalist Papers, a series of articles that argued for adoption of the federal Constitution. Hoping to forestall ratification of the new Constitution, Hamilton had used these essays to argue that a bill of rights, including protections of …

PolitiFact | Fact-checking ’Hamilton’ the musical

’Hamilton’ is largely faithful to Alexander Hamilton’s life, with some details changed for dramatic license … but he wasn’t the deciding “vote,” as the musical … “The Election of 1800 …

Read This Electoral College Quote From Hamilton – Bustle

Today, Hamilton Electors are trying to convince at least 37 Republican electors to vote for alternative GOP choice John Kasich on Dec. 19, hoping for a similar result in the Adams-Jefferson …

The Controversial Election of Thomas Jefferson in 1800 – ThoughtCo

Updated on September 05, 2019. The election of 1800 was one of the most controversial in American history, marked by intrigue, betrayals, and a tie in the electoral college between two candidates who were running mates on the same ticket. The eventual winner was decided only after days of balloting in the House of Representatives.

Why did Hamilton pick Jefferson over Burr? – AskingLot.com

The highly influential Federalist Alexander Hamilton, who mistrusted Jefferson but hated Burr more, persuaded the House to vote against Burr, whom he called the most unfit manfor the office of president. (This accusation and others led Burr to challenge Hamilton to a duel in 1804 that resulted in Hamilton’s death.) Similarly, how did Alexander …

What Alexander Hamilton, Founders Said About Impeachment : NPR

Nov 18, 2019What Alexander Hamilton, … president to court foreign assistance for a political campaign, it’s not impeachable and ultimately voters should decide Trump’s fate in the 2020 election. …

Why did Alexander Hamilton endorse Jefferson for presidency … – Quora

Answer (1 of 10): So Robert J. Kolker’s answer below is correct (and he added a great link to a historical document to boot!) … As Robert noted, the TL,DR version is that Hamilton viewed Jefferson as the lesser of two evils. I’ll add a little more color, in contemporary language, just for a…

What Helps Voters Decide?: Comments on Congress: Hamilton’s Views …

Lee Hamilton is a Senior Advisor for the Indiana University Center on Representative Government; a Distinguished Scholar at the IU Hamilton Lugar School of Global and International Studies; and a Professor of Practice at the IU O’Neill School of Public and Environmental Affairs. He was a member of the U.S. House of Representatives for 34 years.

Maryland Today | From ’Hamilton’ to ’Unlawful’ Voting

From ’Hamilton’ to ’Unlawful’ Voting 5 Moments That Changed Presidential Election History … The episode raises questions of “media, journalism, print journalism, social media, deciding when to call an election,” said Dunning. “Certainly there’s lots of talk (about that) this year, and for reasons far more serious than a desire …

Hamilton’s pandemic election: Will we know who won at the end of voting …

The pandemic could slow voting on Sept. 20 — and maybe leave us hanging for days over who actually won the election. … for example — mail-in ballots could be the deciding factor in …

Hamilton Would Not Have Stood for Trump’s New … – The Atlantic

The limitations stem from Hamilton’s vision of the virtues of what classical philosophers such as Plato, Aristotle, Polybius, and Cicero called “mixed government.”. Plato identified three …

It’s election day. Here’s what you need to know for … – Hamilton News

Here’s what you need to know for voting in the Hamilton area Find out about your riding, local candidates, their platforms and more Set Ancaster as My Local news

Thomas Jefferson, Aaron Burr and the Election of 1800

John Ferling. November 1, 2004. In the 1800 election, Thomas Jefferson, left, and Aaron Burr each received 73 electoral votes, but public opinion sided with Jefferson. The Granger Collection, New …

Rep. Hamilton Announces He Will Not Seek Re-election

Hamilton said he made the decision to not seek re-election after spending time with his family during the holidays and deciding to refocus on what should be prioritized in their lives. “Eighteen years ago, Lynee and I sat our children down and collectively we decided that I should run for the Minnesota House of Representatives,” Hamilton said.

2022 Hamilton, Ontario municipal election – Wikipedia

The 2022 Hamilton municipal election is an upcoming municipal election that will occur on 24 October 2022, as per the Ontario Municipal Elections Act, 1996. Residents of Hamilton will select one mayor, members of the Hamilton City Council, as well as members of both the English and French Public and Catholic School Boards using a first-past-the-post electoral system in single-member …

Jefferson and Hamilton, Political Rivals in Washington’s Cabinet

Jefferson and Hamilton, Political Rivals. Election Inauguration First Term (1789-1792) Second Term (1793-1797) Ten Facts About Washington’s Presidency. Joanne B. Freeman, Professor of History Yale University. Differences of opinion didn’t concern President Washington. They could even be useful, until he came to realize (in 1792), the very …

What Hamilton Leaves Out About The Jefferson/Burr 1800 Election

The final vote of the contingent election declared Jefferson the winner and, as Hamilton explained it was indeed a landslide — but it didn’t start that way. There was a high amount of pressure for the House to decide on a Presidential Elect; the new nation was quickly approaching a civil war, and the eyes of the world were on America after the Revolutionary War.

PolitiFact | Fact-checking ’Hamilton’ the musical

’Hamilton’ is largely faithful to Alexander Hamilton’s life, with some details changed for dramatic license … but he wasn’t the deciding “vote,” as the musical … “The Election of 1800 …

Resource

https://www.history.com/news/aaron-burr-alexander-hamilton-election-1800
https://itshamiltime.com/2012/11/19/the-election-of-1800-hamiltons-role/
https://screenrant.com/hamilton-musical-true-story-election-1800-missing-information/
https://www.tampabay.com/life-culture/2020/07/03/politifact-fact-checking-hamilton-the-musical/
https://www.vox.com/2015/11/28/9801376/hamilton-election-of-1800-burr-jefferson
https://www.biography.com/news/why-alexander-hamilton-never-became-president
https://www.elle.com/culture/movies-tv/a33106521/hamilton-musical-true-story/
https://constitutioncenter.org/interactive-constitution/blog/burr-vs-hamilton-behind-the-ultimate-political-feud
https://www.history.com/news/whose-vision-of-america-won-out-hamiltons-or-jeffersons
https://www.reddit.com/r/hamiltonmusical/comments/9ct8wv/a_question_about_the_election_of_1800/
https://www.ocpathink.org/post/hamilton-on-the-electoral-college
https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/americanexperience/features/duel-hamilton-and-us-constitution/
https://mtsu.edu/first-amendment/article/1162/alexander-hamilton
https://www.politifact.com/article/2020/jul/01/fact-checking-hamilton-musical/
https://www.bustle.com/articles/200028-what-did-alexander-hamilton-say-about-the-electoral-college-he-inspired-a-group-of-faithless-electors
https://www.thoughtco.com/election-of-1800-deadlock-broken-1773859
https://askinglot.com/why-did-hamilton-pick-jefferson-over-burr
https://www.npr.org/2019/11/18/779938819/fractured-into-factions-what-the-founders-feared-about-impeachment
https://www.quora.com/Why-did-Alexander-Hamilton-endorse-Jefferson-for-presidency-despite-having-many-public-disagreements?share=1
https://corg.iu.edu/programs/hamilton-views/comments-on-congress/What%20Helps%20Voters%20Decide%20.html
https://today.umd.edu/hamilton-unlawful-voting-e5e8c892-f777-4059-8b28-b42ee5cebd46
https://www.thespec.com/news/hamilton-region/2021/09/20/hamilton-covid-19-election.html
https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2020/04/hamilton-would-not-have-stood-trumps-new-constitutional-theory/610177/
https://www.thespec.com/local-ancaster/news/2021/09/20/it-s-election-day-here-s-what-you-need-to-know-for-voting-in-the-hamilton-area.html
https://www.smithsonianmag.com/history/thomas-jefferson-aaron-burr-and-the-election-of-1800-131082359/
https://www.house.leg.state.mn.us/members/profile/news/12264/47022
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2022_Hamilton,_Ontario_municipal_election
https://www.mountvernon.org/george-washington/the-first-president/washingtons-presidential-cabinet/jefferson-and-hamilton-political-rivals/
https://screenrant.com/hamilton-musical-true-story-election-1800-missing-information/
https://www.politifact.com/article/2020/jul/01/fact-checking-hamilton-musical/