Skip to content

Did Sword Fights Really Happen

The sword fights you see in the movies probably aren’t all that true to the realities of medieval fighting, as you might imagine. Besides the fact that enemies likely didn’t pause to trade carefully worded insults, Hollywood fight choreography is much more elegant than a real fight to the death.

However, this popular genre has led to people getting the wrong idea about how a real sword fight actually went down, and spouting off these misconceptions as fact. For example….

Swords were used in war, for duels and personal defence (and this is just Europe!) for more than 2000 years. I’ll give you a short and quick run-down. During the Greek and Roman classical eras, swords were the weapon of barbarians mostly.

More Answers On Did Sword Fights Really Happen

Did sword fights really occur as portrayed in movies/TV? – Quora

Answer (1 of 6): Nope. A lot of sword fights in modern entertainment are for show, not function. In a real sword fight, combatants are out to hurt each other in horrible ways. A real sword fight would be a brutal, bloody affair, and depending on the context, would be much shorter than is often sh…

What was sword fighting actually like? Did it occur during war?

Roman soldiers were very well trained, and their fighting style was somewhat like boxing – they used their shield to block and their sword to “punch” – going in for quick stabs where they could. When they fought the Hellenistic armies that were unaccustomed to these tactics, they sure did shock their enemies. 71.

How did sword fights actually work? – Quora

Answer (1 of 8): All swords fights are the same as all fights: hit the other guy and don’t get it. Usually a fight is over in a few seconds, but it can take time if both combatants know what they’re doing and defend themselves well. This usually isn’t the case, but its not unheard of. Two ways t…

“Facts” About Swords and Sword Fighting That Are Actually BS

A sword never has to be replaced, never has to be sharpened, sometimes even the blood just vanishes from the blade without so much as a wet rag. No wonder people are under the mistaken impression that a sword is an invincible weapon. However, a sword is not infallible, swords broke all the time in battle, they wore out, they needed to be replaced.

How did sword fights actually play out in real life? I imagine it was …

Having done a variety of sword-fighting, it really depends on the weapons (and armor) used, the skill of the users, and the terms of combat. The most glorified sword duels in history generally involved sabres or rapiers. Most of these duels were to first blood, meaning that first successful hit ended the duel. As a result, the combatants fought …

What Historic Sword Fighting Actually Looked Like | Mental Floss

The sword fights you see in the movies probably aren’t all that true to the realities of medieval fighting, as you might imagine. Besides the fact that enemies likely didn’t pause to trade …

Sword Fighting is Not What You Think…

The truth is, that most all our conceptions of sword fighting get it wrong. The reality of it is not what you think it is. Face it, some readers will really get offended if you dare to suggest that they don’t have an accurate conception of sword fighting. Fanboys especially will take it as a personal insult to their very identify when you …

What was sword fighting actually like? Did it occur during war?

Did sword fights really happen? What were they really like? Did they truly happen in war battles or were they reserved for special tournaments? 466 Upvotes. permalink; reddit; 93% Upvoted. → 1.2k. u/vonadler Dec 21 ’12 edited Dec 21 ’12. You are asking a VERY wide question. …

This is what really happens when swords hit armour – Eurogamer

This actually happened by the way. … was a very long-winded way of saying that most games or even TV shows and films don’t realistically portray what would actually happen in a sword fight with …

The Most Incredible Sword Fights in History – Only Knives

The “Sandbar Fight” — which first brought the Bowie knife to the attention of the world — began with pistols, then progressed to sword and Bowie knife. An article published in the New York Times on January 27th, 1895, describes the events in what should be accurate detail, although the fight actually happened on September 18th, 1827, and …

Did Roman Gladiators fight to the death? (A complete guide)

Sep 9, 2021Actually, we would probably call it a dagger instead of a sword. These gladiator swords were about 11,8 inches long and weighed around 1.3 to 1.5 pounds. The kind of injury that a weapon like that could inflict was just as limited as the „Fencing” one could do with that kind of sword.

What Historic Sword Fighting Actually Looked Like | Mental Floss

The sword fights you see in the movies probably aren’t all that true to the realities of medieval fighting, as you might imagine. Besides the fact that enemies likely didn’t pause to trade …

How did sword fights actually play out in real life?

TL:DR Sword fights in medieval times were short, brutal and often resolved with one stab to a vital area due to an opponent being unbalanced by being hit with a shield or well timed blow. level 1. · 5 yr. ago. Haven’t seen many sword fights but I have seen a lot of knife fights. They are swift and super fucking brutal.

Do sword and gun fights happen in real life as they do in movies?

Answer (1 of 3): Well … movies tend to portray sword fights in several different dimensions. Virtually none of the actual moves used in sword fights work, but that probably isn’t a surprise; everybody knows that stage fighting is stage fighting. But what about what the things aside from the indiv…

What were sword fights really like? – reddit

In the medieval times swords were often used as clubs as they were as blades. Punches were thrown in combat, every advantage was used. But fighting in the renaissance became much more formalized, and much quicker. The Blade and the Gauche was all that touched skin during what would be considered a “formal” duel.

Japanese sword fighting: All about the discipline – Japan Accents

Another popular form of Japanese martial arts that includes Japanese sword fighting style is aikido. Aikido was founded by Morihei Ueshiba in the mid-20th century. He created his martial art specifically to honor the sword as a bringer of peace. Morihei’s technique in sword-wielding focuses on calmness of movement, much like a form of …

Are the sword fights in the show realistic? – General (GoT) – A Forum …

So I have a big problem with Hollywood swordfights, the ones where people spin around and dance and do a 360 spin turn to meet the other sword. This shit didn’t happen back then, whether it was the Viking age when Saxon/Celtic and Viking steel met in the shores and meadows of Britain and Ireland,…

realism – How realistic was the sword fight in Rob Roy? – Movies & TV …

One previous question asked about the authenticity of sword fights in Game of Thrones compared to actual “medieval” sword fighting–a rather vague standard. Naturally, such choreography is made for the screen and pales to movies like the epic duels in Scaramouche (1952) which were based on real fencing moves. Of course, while realistic, to what extent this Olympic-style fencing represented the …

Wait, Where Did Hopper Get That Sword From? | Screen Rant

Hopper’s Sword In Stranger Things Belonged To Schwarzenegger’s Conan. Hopper finding the sword and using it to kill the Demogorgon isn’t just a satisfying moment but it also has a cool behind-the-scenes story. David Harbour revealed in an interview with GQ that the sword is the same one used by Arnold Schwarzenegger in the 1982 movie …

Did People in the Middle Ages Fight as Well With Swords as Portrayed in …

Other classes would not have been as skilled, though the popularity of medieval sword manuals shows that sword fighting skills were highly prized. And cheap swords were easy to come by — in late medieval England a man could buy a cheap, mass-produced sword for as little as sixpence, though a better quality blade would set him back 1-2 shillings.

Is it True if You Live by the Sword You Will Die by the Sword?

In the Gospel of Matthew, Matthew records what happened the night Jesus was betrayed in the Garden of Gethsemane, “’Put your sword back in its place,’ Jesus said to him, ’for all who draw the sword will die by the sword’” (Matthew 26:52).It is helpful to understand the broader context of this verse in order to ascertain the meaning of Jesus’ statement.

Fight Master Breaks Down Sword Fighting From Film & TV – Wired

Sword fighting expert Christina Traister examines a variety of scenes from movies and television featuring sword fighting and applies her expert analysis. … fight to the death would be a really …

The Most Incredible Sword Fights in History – Only Knives

The “Sandbar Fight” — which first brought the Bowie knife to the attention of the world — began with pistols, then progressed to sword and Bowie knife. An article published in the New York Times on January 27th, 1895, describes the events in what should be accurate detail, although the fight actually happened on September 18th, 1827, and …

One Piece: 10 Fights That Almost Happened (But Never Did)

6 Ace and Luffy vs. Akainu. Had Luffy not been caught off guard by Ace’s vivre card being dropped, Ace’s death might’ve occurred at a different point in the story. As a result, both Luffy and Ace would’ve been forced to fend off Admiral Akainu at the same time. Having never had the chance to legitimately fight together, the resulting battle …

How Long did Medieval Sword Fights last? – neutralhistory.com

June 2022. Medieval swordfights are one of the most commonly depicted and debated parts of the Middle Ages. But while Hollywood loves to show long sword fights that last for half an hour or even longer others like to portray sword fights as something that was usually over within a couple of sword moves. Both opinions are extremes that can not …

This is what really happens when swords hit armour – Eurogamer

This actually happened by the way. … was a very long-winded way of saying that most games or even TV shows and films don’t realistically portray what would actually happen in a sword fight with …

Castlevania Season 4’s Ending, Explained: What Happens to Trevor … – CBR

Eventually, when things seem bleakest, Trevor plunges a dagger that he got in Targoviste straight into the being’s head. As Death explodes, Trevor is seemingly wiped from existence. Two weeks later, Trevor is presumed dead in the battle against Death. Alucard and his love interest, Greta, are working to restore the castle and essentially turn …

Sword Master Rates Sword Fights for Realism in Movies and TV

Download the app. Sword master rates 10 more iconic sword fights from movies and TV. Professional swordsman Dave Rawlings reacts to 10 fight scenes featuring longswords and daggers and rates them based on their historical and technical accuracy. Rawlings rates the skill of lightsaber fights in “The Mandalorian” (2020) and “Star Wars Rebels” (2017).

Johnny Depp’s Pirates stuntman on horrific injury and bond with … – Metro

’It was a sword fight on the run in the sand and the water over 100 yards long and we had to shoot it in master [a film recording of an entire scene, start to finish, from a camera angle that …

Yes, Mandingo Fighting Really Happened – History Banter

Yes, Mandingo Fighting Really Happened. In Quentin Tarantino s film D Jango Unchained, two black slaves engage in a no-holds-barred fight for the amusement of white southern plantation owners. When one slave beats the other to the point that he can fight no longer, Calvin Candy, a slave master portrayed by Leonardo DiCaprio, instructs the …

Resource

https://www.quora.com/Did-sword-fights-really-occur-as-portrayed-in-movies-TV?share=1
https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/157upf/what_was_sword_fighting_actually_like_did_it/
https://www.quora.com/How-did-sword-fights-actually-work?share=1
https://www.weirdworm.com/facts-about-swords-and-sword-fighting-that-are-actually-bs/
https://www.reddit.com/r/AskReddit/comments/uh4iq/how_did_sword_fights_actually_play_out_in_real/
https://www.mentalfloss.com/article/70414/what-historic-sword-fighting-actually-looked
https://www.thearma.org/essays/Swordfighting-Not.html
https://dancebeam.wilsonema.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/157upf/what_was_sword_fighting_actually_like_did_it/
https://www.eurogamer.net/this-is-what-really-happens-when-swords-hit-armour
http://www.onlyknives.com/most-incredible-sword-fights-in-history/3/
https://neutralhistory.com/did-roman-gladiators-fight-to-the-death/
https://www.mentalfloss.com/article/70414/what-historic-sword-fighting-actually-looked
https://www.reddit.com/r/AskReddit/comments/6d92kf/how_did_sword_fights_actually_play_out_in_real/
https://www.quora.com/Do-sword-and-gun-fights-happen-in-real-life-as-they-do-in-movies?share=1
https://www.reddit.com/r/AskReddit/comments/22yvrj/what_were_sword_fights_really_like/
https://www.japanaccents.com/swords/japanese-sword-fighting
https://asoiaf.westeros.org/index.php?/topic/83444-are-the-sword-fights-in-the-show-realistic/
https://movies.stackexchange.com/questions/66458/how-realistic-was-the-sword-fight-in-rob-roy
https://screenrant.com/where-did-hoppers-sword-come-from-in-stranger-things/
https://www.huffpost.com/entry/did-people-in-the-middle_b_7700354
https://www.christianity.com/wiki/bible/is-it-true-if-you-live-by-the-sword-you-will-die-by-the-sword.html
https://www.wired.com/video/watch/sword-fighting-technique-critique
http://www.onlyknives.com/most-incredible-sword-fights-in-history/3/
https://www.cbr.com/one-piece-fights-should-have-happened/
https://neutralhistory.com/how-long-did-medieval-sword-fights-last/
https://www.eurogamer.net/this-is-what-really-happens-when-swords-hit-armour
https://www.cbr.com/castlevania-season-4-ending-explained-trevor-dracula-survive/
https://www.insider.com/sword-master-rates-10-more-iconic-sword-fights-movies-and-tv-2020
https://metro.co.uk/2020/08/28/johnny-depps-pirates-caribbean-stunt-double-career-ending-injury-epic-fight-scenes-gift-actor-13119975/
https://historybanter.com/did-mandingo-fighting-really-happen/