Skip to content

Did Atiyah Prove The Riemann Hypothesis

The Riemann hypothesis is one of seven math problems that can win you $1 million from the Clay Mathematics Institute if you can solve it. British mathematician Sir Michael Atiyah claimed on Monday that he solved the 160-year-old problem. Atiyah has already won the the Fields Medal and the Abel Prize in his career.

The Riemann hypothesis, a formula related to the distribution of prime numbers, has remained unsolved for more than a century.

The Riemann hypothesis is one of seven math problems that can win you $1 million from the Clay Mathematics Institute if you can solve it. British mathematician Sir Michael Atiyah claimed on Monday that he solved the 160-year-old problem. Atiyah has already won the the Fields Medal and the Abel Prize in his career.

At the 2018 Heidelberg Laureate Forum, he claimed to have solved the Riemann hypothesis, Hilbert’s eighth problem, by contradiction using the fine-structure constant. Again, the proof did not hold up and the hypothesis remains one of the six unsolved Millennium Prize Problems in mathematics, as of 2022.

He gave a counterexample for n = 4. On the other hand, if all representations in L2(Γ∖PGLn(F)) are generic, then he proved that the validity of the Riemann hypothesis for all Zr(XΓ, u) and strongly Ramanujan are equivalent.

Dr Kumar Eswaran first published his solution to the Riemann Hypothesis in 2016, but has received mixed responses from peers. A USD 1 million prize awaits the person with the final solution.

We haven’t made any progress on the Riemann hypothesis in 150 years, whereas this is a question we can make incremental progress towards. Complex numbers have two parts, one real and one imaginary, the latter of which relates to the imaginary number i, defined as the square root of −1.

Has anyone proved the Riemann hypothesis?

The Riemann hypothesis, a formula related to the distribution of prime numbers, has remained unsolved for more than a century.

Did Michael Atiyah prove the Riemann hypothesis?

The most recent famous claim came in September, 2018 from British-Lebenese mathematician Sir Micheal Atiyah. He used Todd functions and mentioned the Fine Structure constant a fundamental physical constant in his proof by contra- diction [17].

Did Atiyah solve Riemann?

At the 2018 Heidelberg Laureate Forum, he claimed to have solved the Riemann hypothesis, Hilbert’s eighth problem, by contradiction using the fine-structure constant. Again, the proof did not hold up and the hypothesis remains one of the six unsolved Millennium Prize Problems in mathematics, as of 2022.

Did Ramanujan prove Riemann hypothesis?

(d) Strongly Ramanujan and the Riemann hypothesis He gave a counterexample for n = 4. On the other hand, if all representations in L2(u0393u2216PGLn(F)) are generic, then he proved that the validity of the Riemann hypothesis for all Zr(Xu0393, u) and strongly Ramanujan are equivalent.

Who has solved Riemann hypothesis?

Dr Kumar Eswaran first published his solution to the Riemann Hypothesis in 2016, but has received mixed responses from peers. A USD 1 million prize awaits the person with the final solution.

Has the Riemann hypothesis been solved 2020?

The Riemann Hypothesis or RH, is a millennium problem, that has remained unsolved for the last 161 years. Hyderabad based mathematical physicist Kumar Easwaran has claimed to have developed proof for ‘The Riemann Hypothesis’ or RH, a millennium problem, that has remained unsolved for the last 161 years.

What happens if Riemann hypothesis is proved?

If the Riemann hypothesis is true, it won’t produce a prime number spectrometer. But the proof should give us more understanding of how the primes work, and therefore the proof might be translated into something that might produce this prime spectrometer.

Did Atiyah prove the Riemann hypothesis?

By describing this constant using a relatively obscure relationship known as the Todd function, Atiyah claimed to be able to prove the Riemann hypothesis by contradiction.

Who Solved the Riemann conjecture?

Dr Kumar Eswaran first published his solution to the Riemann Hypothesis in 2016, but has received mixed responses from peers. A USD 1 million prize awaits the person with the final solution.

Is Riemann hypothesis solved 2021?

“As far as I am concerned, the Riemann Hypothesis remains open,” said Martin Bridson, president of Clay Mathematics Institute, when asked about the claim by Hyderabad-based Kumar Eswaran of solving the problem that has puzzled mathematicians for past 162 years.

Did Ramanujan solved Riemann hypothesis?

But Littlewood had to say, “The stuff about primes is wrong”—explaining that Ramanujan incorrectly assumed the Riemann zeta function didn’t have zeros off the real axis, even though it actually has an infinite number of them, which are the subject of the whole Riemann hypothesis.

Who proved the Riemann hypothesis?

The Riemann hypothesis builds on the prime number theorem, conjectured by Carl Friedrich Gauss in the 1790s and proved in the 1890s by Jacques Hadamard and, independently, by Charles-Jean de La Vallée Poussin.

Did Riemann prove his hypothesis?

Most mathematicians believe that the Riemann hypothesis is indeed true. Calculations so far have not yielded any misbehaving zeros that do not lie in the critical line. However, there are infinitely many of these zeros to check, and so a computer calculation will not verify all that much.

Is Riemann hypothesis solved by Indian?

According to Times of India, Easwaran, who is a mathematical physicist at Sreenidhi Institute of Science and Technology, Hyderabad, had placed his research titled ‘The final and exhaustive proof of the Riemann Hypothesis from first principles’ on the internet almost five years ago.

Is the Riemann hypothesis solved Kumar Eswaran?

No. The link leads to one of the misguided announcements about Kumar Eswaran’s incorrect proof. The Riemann Hypothesis remains unproven.

Is the Riemann hypothesis solved 2020?

The Riemann Hypothesis or RH, is a millennium problem, that has remained unsolved for the last 161 years. Hyderabad based mathematical physicist Kumar Easwaran has claimed to have developed proof for ‘The Riemann Hypothesis’ or RH, a millennium problem, that has remained unsolved for the last 161 years.

More Answers On Did Atiyah Prove The Riemann Hypothesis

Atiyah Riemann Hypothesis proof: final thoughts – The Aperiodical

Firstly, it’s become clear that the work presented by Atiyah doesn’t constitute a proof of the Riemann Hypothesis, so the Clay Institute can rest easy with their 1 million dollars, and encryption on the internet remains safe.

How did Sir Michael Atiyah prove the Riemann hypothesis? – Quora

I’m afraid the only honest answer to this question is No. Atiyah’s presentation on the Riemann Hypothesis did not amount to a proof or germ of a proof of anything, and I wish people would forget about this sad incident and remember Atiyah for his actual spectacular achievements.

On Michael Atiyah and the Riemann Hypothesis – AMS Blogs

At the 2018 Heidelberg Laureate Forum (HLF), Sir Michael Atiyah gave a lecture in which he claimed to have found a proof for the Riemann hypothesis. If Atiyah’s proof holds up, then the nearly 160 year problem concerning the distribution of primes will finally have a solution.

Riemann hypothesis likely remains unsolved despite claimed proof

One of the most famous unsolved problems in mathematics likely remains unsolved. At a hotly-anticipated talk at the Heidelberg Laureate Forum today, retired mathematician Michael Atiyah delivered…

For real? Atiyah’s proof of the Riemann hypothesis – Aleph Zero Categorical

The topic: a proof of the Riemann hypothesis. The Riemann hypothesis states that the Riemann Zeta function defined by the analytic continuation of $zeta(s) = sum_{n=1}^infty n^{-s}$ has nontrivial zeros only on the critical line whose numbers have real part $1/2$. Check out this MathWorld article for more details.

No, Riemann Hypothesis has NOT been solved, yet! – Gaurav Tiwari

The proof provided by Dr. K Easwaran (also: K. Eswaran) has already been declared flawed when he submitted it in 2018. Year after year he has been submitting the same paper with some modifications but as the foundation is flawed, the conclusion — no matter how hard you try, will always be flawed. No, Riemann Hypothesis has NOT been solved, yet!

Why I’m Sceptical About The Claim That Riemann Hypothesis Has Been …

In an earlier essay in these pages, I examined an earlier claim to have solved the Riemann Hypothesis (“Standing on the shoulders of zeroes”, 28 September 2018. The essay outlined the Hypothesis …

Riemann hypothesis – Wikipedia

Dudek (2014) proved that the Riemann hypothesis implies that for all there is a prime satisfying . This is an explicit version of a theorem of Cramér . Growth of arithmetic functions The Riemann hypothesis implies strong bounds on the growth of many other arithmetic functions, in addition to the primes counting function above.

Riemann Hypothesis Solved by Sir Michael Atiyah After 160 Years, He Says

The Riemann hypothesis is one of seven math problems that can win you $1 million from the Clay Mathematics Institute if you can solve it. British mathematician Sir Michael Atiyah claimed on Monday that he solved the 160-year-old problem. Atiyah has already won the the Fields Medal and the Abel Prize in his career.

Riemann Hypothesis: Michael Atiyah Claims to Have Solved One of Math’s …

Over the past few days, the mathematics world has been abuzz over the news that Sir Michael Atiyah, the famous Fields Medalist and Abel Prize winner, claims to have solved the Riemann hypothesis….

Mathematician Claims He Solved 160-Year-Old Math Problem. Critics Say …

Michael Atiyah, a prominent mathematician emeritus at the University of Edinburgh, announced yesterday (Sept. 24) at the Heidelberg Laureate Forum in Germany that he had come up with a simple proof…

Michael Atiyah claims proof of Riemann Hypothesis – Aperiodical

Michael Atiyah claims proof of Riemann Hypothesis By Katie Steckles. Posted September 22, 2018 in News Is Sir Michael Atiyah giving lecture on Monday Sept. 25 @ #HLF18? Yes. Will he presenenting a proof of the Riemann Hypothesis? Yes, that is what his abstract says. pic.twitter.com/v1dJhUUUEk

The History and Importance of the Riemann Hypothesis

Here we are interested in the eighth: Prove the Riemann hypothesis, the Goldbach conjecture, and the twin prime conjecture. [3] “Recently, significant advances have been made in the theory of the distribution of prime numbers by Hadamard, de La Vallee-Poussin, V. Mangoldt, and others. However, in order to completely solve the problems posed by Riemann’s treatise ‘On the Number of Primes …

Michael Atiyah: Has the Riemann hypothesis been ‘solved’?

The Riemann hypothesis is named after the German mathematician G.F.B Riemann, who observed that the frequency of prime numbers is very closely related to the behaviour of an elaborate function. If you’re confused already, you’re supposed to be – this equation has baffled the mathematics world for over a century.

If Atiyah does manage to prove the Riemann hypothesis, how will that …

You can’t take anything away from Atiyah who is obviously a monster mathematician with great theorems. But the HLF has decided to whore out a sick man for their own publicity purposes to promote their own wanky conference. He didn’t prove that S^6 has no complex structure, and he didn’t prove the Riemann Hypothesis.

Sir Michael Atiyah Riemann Hypothesis Proof Interview

Professor Atiyah is not the one to find the formula he is proclaiming to have generated. In fact it was Dr. Gabriel Oyibo, in 1990, that formulated the GAGUT. THE BEST WAY TO SEPARATE THE TRUTH, IS GET BOTH PARTIES’ STATEMENT. SOMEONE DID NOT DO THEIR HOMEWORK BEFORE PRINTING.

Riemann Hypothesis Solved by Sir Michael Atiyah After 160 Years, He Says

Riemann Hypothesis Solved by Sir Michael Atiyah After 160 Years, He Says US Markets Open In the news Dow Jones -0.37% Nasdaq +0.25% S&P 500 -0.21% Home Science Contributors Top mathematician says…

A British mathematician thinks he’s cracked a secret worth a … – PopSci

Atiyah solves (i.e. proves) the Riemann hypothesis by “contradiction,” a kind of proof that involves assuming the problem at hand is untrue, and trying to prove it by showing that these …

Top Mathematician Claims He’s Solved a $1 Million Hypothesis. But There …

30 SEPTEMBER 2018. Over the past few days, the mathematics world has been abuzz over the news that Sir Michael Atiyah, the famous Fields Medalist and Abel Prize winner, claims to have solved the Riemann hypothesis. If his proof turns out to be correct, this would be one of the most important mathematical achievements in many years.

Has the Riemann hypothesis been ‘solved’? Who is Michael Atiyah? And …

Retired mathematician Michael Atiyah said he will present “simple proof” of the Riemann hypothesis while attending a talk in Germany this week.. The 90-year old has said he expects a backlash from …

Mathematician claims to have solved 160-year-old Reimann hypothesis

The Riemann hypothesis is one of seven unsolved “Millennium Prizes” from CMI, each worth $1m (£760,000). What is the Riemann hypothesis, and how did Atiyah solve it?

Riemann Hypothesis: Michael Atiyah Claims to Have Solved One of Math’s …

Over the past few days, the mathematics world has been abuzz over the news that Sir Michael Atiyah, the famous Fields Medalist and Abel Prize winner, claims to have solved the Riemann hypothesis….

Michael Atiyah claims proof of Riemann Hypothesis – Aperiodical

— Heidelberg Laureate Forum (@HLForum) September 20, 2018 The internet is buzzing with the news: algebraic topologist and geometer Sir Michael Atiyah has announced that at his talk next Monday at the Heidelberg Laureate Forum, he will deliver a simple new proof of the long-standing Riemann Hypothesis.

Here’s why we care about attempts to prove the Riemann hypothesis

The hypothesis, which could unlock the mysteries of prime numbers, has never been proved. But mathematicians are buzzing about a new attempt. Esteemed mathematician Michael Atiyah took a crack at…

Heres why we care about attempts to prove the Riemann hypothesis …

The hypothesis, which could unlock the mysteries of prime numbers, has never been proved. But mathematicians are buzzing about a new attempt. Esteemed mathematician Michael Atiyah took a crack at proving the hypothesis in a lecture at the Heidelberg Laureate Forum in Germany on September 24.

Has the Riemann hypothesis been proven? | Page 3 | Physics Forums

Did Atiyah write the paper this way on purpose, knowing it would probably only be understandable by the older readers? As I have argued in my earlier posts including #68 in this thread, much of the controversy seems to stem from the way this paper is written. I haven’t tracked down Weyl’s book yet, so this remains speculation. In either case …

Atiyah and the Fine-Structure Constant – Sean Carroll

As Atiyah notes, in some sense α is a fundamental dimensionless numerical quantity like e or π. As such it is tempting to try to “derive” its value from some deeper principles. Arthur Eddington famously tried to derive exactly 1/137, but failed; Atiyah cites him approvingly. But to a modern physicist, this seems like a misguided quest.

PDF

THE RIEMANN HYPOTHESIS MICHAEL ATIYAH 1. Introduction In my Abel lecture [1] at the ICM in Rio de Janeiro 2018, I explained how to solve a long-standing mathematical problem that had emerged from physics.

Mathematicians Sceptical Of Supposed Million-Dollar Proof

Riemann hypothesised, but did not prove, … “Unfortunately it appears that Atiyah’s paper on the Riemann hypothesis suffers from some internal inconsistencies as it is currently written …

Mathematicians prove result tied to the Riemann hypothesis

The Riemann hypothesis was first posed by the German mathematician Georg Friedrich Bernhard Riemann in 1859, in a paper where he observed that questions regarding the distribution of prime numbers were closely tied to a conjecture regarding the behavior of the “zeta function,” namely the beguilingly simple expression ζ(s) = ∞ ∑ n=1 1 …

Resource

https://aperiodical.com/2018/09/atiyah-riemann-hypothesis-proof-final-thoughts/
https://www.quora.com/How-did-Sir-Michael-Atiyah-prove-the-Riemann-hypothesis?share=1
https://blogs.ams.org/blogonmathblogs/2018/10/01/on-michael-atiyah-and-the-riemann-hypothesis/
https://www.newscientist.com/article/2180504-riemann-hypothesis-likely-remains-unsolved-despite-claimed-proof/
https://blog.jpolak.org/?p=2050
https://gauravtiwari.org/riemann-hypothesis-has-not-been-solved/
https://www.livemint.com/opinion/columns/why-i-m-sceptical-about-the-claim-that-riemann-hypothesis-has-been-proven-11624992131377.html
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Riemann_hypothesis
https://www.insider.com/riemann-hypothesis-solved-by-sir-michael-atiyah-after-160-years-he-says-2018-9
https://www.newsweek.com/riemann-hypothesis-million-dollar-math-mystery-michael-atiyah-1146244
https://www.livescience.com/63668-riemann-hypothesis-solution-critics.html
https://aperiodical.com/2018/09/michael-atiyah-claims-proof-of-riemann-hypothesis/
https://www.physicsforums.com/insights/the-history-and-importance-of-the-riemann-hypothesis/
https://www.tunisiesoir.com/science/michael-atiyah-has-the-riemann-hypothesis-been-solved-7863-2018/
https://www.reddit.com/r/math/comments/9hjizo/if_atiyah_does_manage_to_prove_the_riemann/
https://tomrocksmaths.com/2018/09/28/sir-michael-atiyah-riemann-hypothesis-proof-interview/
https://www.businessinsider.com/riemann-hypothesis-solved-by-sir-michael-atiyah-after-160-years-he-says-2018-9?op=1
https://www.popsci.com/riemann-hypothesis-proof/
https://www.sciencealert.com/has-math-s-1-million-mystery-really-been-solved
https://www.standard.co.uk/news/uk/has-the-riemann-hypothesis-been-solved-who-is-michael-atiyah-a3944486.html
https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/riemann-hypothesis-uk-mathematics-solved-claim-sir-michael-atiyah-a8557656.html
https://www.newsweek.com/riemann-hypothesis-million-dollar-math-mystery-michael-atiyah-1146244
https://aperiodical.com/2018/09/michael-atiyah-claims-proof-of-riemann-hypothesis/
https://www.sciencenews.org/article/why-we-care-riemann-hypothesis-math-prime-numbers
https://www.bnreport.com/en/heres-why-we-care-about-attempts-to-prove-the-riemann-hypothesis/
https://www.physicsforums.com/threads/has-the-riemann-hypothesis-been-proven.955832/page-3
https://www.preposterousuniverse.com/blog/2018/09/25/atiyah-and-the-fine-structure-constant/
https://ep00.epimg.net/descargables/2018/09/25/b133e2bf9a3e7bb55f5fae26dcf9b8c0.pdf
https://www.gizmodo.com.au/2018/09/mathematicians-sceptical-of-supposed-million-dollar-proof/
https://mathscholar.org/2019/05/mathematicians-prove-result-tied-to-the-riemann-hypothesis/