Skip to content

Could A Roman Legion Defeat A Medieval Army

Ultimately, the Romans would almost certainly win a hand-to-hand, face-to-face fight, but Medieval warfare no longer revolved around that, and the heavy Knights and Longbowmen would likely make short work of the Legions before they could close for battle.

The Carthaginians and their allies, led by Hannibal, surrounded and practically annihilated a larger Roman and Italian army under the consuls Lucius Aemilius Paullus and Gaius Terentius Varro. It is regarded as one of the greatest tactical feats in military history and one of the worst defeats in Roman history.

The Roman way was very expensive. For most of its existence Rome had a standing army, which was disciplined and capable of those formations. But Rome was a large relatively centralized empire with a significant tax base.

According to the history of the Roman Empire, Legio IX Hispana was the most feared Roman Legion.

Were the Romans more advanced than the Middle Ages?

The Roman Empire was one of the most technologically advanced civilizations of antiquity, with some of the more advanced concepts and inventions forgotten during the turbulent eras of Late Antiquity and the early Middle Ages.

What army beat the Romans?

The Carthaginians and their allies, led by Hannibal, surrounded and practically annihilated a larger Roman and Italian army under the consuls Lucius Aemilius Paullus and Gaius Terentius Varro. It is regarded as one of the greatest tactical feats in military history and one of the worst defeats in Roman history.

Why didn’t medieval armies use Roman tactics?

They didn’t have time for that. And no one had the kind of money it would take to turn them into that. At least not at first (later when they might the system was entrenched). Your infantry might be supplemented by mercenaries, who would be more trained and disciplined but weren’t particularly loyal to your cause.

What was the most feared Roman Legion?

According to the history of the Roman Empire, Legio IX Hispana was the most feared Roman Legion.

Was Roman Empire more advanced than medieval?

The Roman Empire was one of the most technologically advanced civilizations of antiquity, with some of the more advanced concepts and inventions forgotten during the turbulent eras of Late Antiquity and the early Middle Ages.

Why was Rome the most advanced?

Rome became the most powerful state in the world by the first century BCE through a combination of military power, political flexibility, economic expansion, and more than a bit of good luck. This expansion changed the Mediterranean world and also changed Rome itself.

How advanced was the Roman Empire?

Although arches existed thousands of years before the time of ancient Rome, the Romans revolutionized the structure by using it to build colosseums, aqueducts, bridges and other buildings. Roman engineers created wooden frames in the shape of an arch, then created the stonework around the frame.

Why were Greeks and Romans so advanced?

Scientifically, The Greeks used lenses for fire-making or defence, development of modern medicine. Greek doctors and scholars were assimilated into Roman society, and great libraries were built, etc. Militarily, the Romans had standing, professional armies, with ranks, training, drills and formations.

Who beat the Romans in war?

In one of the most decisive battles in history, a large Roman army under Valens, the Roman emperor of the East, is defeated by the Visigoths at the Battle of Adrianople in present-day Turkey. Two-thirds of the Roman army, including Emperor Valens himself, were overrun and slaughtered by the mounted barbarians.

What army beat Rome?

In September AD 9 half of Rome’s Western army was ambushed in a German forest. Three legions, comprising some 25,000 men under the Roman General Varus, were wiped out by an army of Germanic tribes under the leadership of Arminius.

What defeated the Romans?

Invasions by Barbarian tribes The most straightforward theory for Western Rome’s collapse pins the fall on a string of military losses sustained against outside forces. Rome had tangled with Germanic tribes for centuries, but by the 300s “barbarian” groups like the Goths had encroached beyond the Empire’s borders.

Did the Romans ever lose a Battle?

When The Romans Lost A Tenth Of Their Armies In A Single Battle – The Disaster Of The Teutoburg Forest. The Roman Empire of the 1st century AD is renowned as one of the most deadly and successful fighting forces in history.

Would Roman tactics work in medieval times?

Ultimately, the Romans would almost certainly win a hand-to-hand, face-to-face fight, but Medieval warfare no longer revolved around that, and the heavy Knights and Longbowmen would likely make short work of the Legions before they could close for battle. Still, it would have been fascinating to see.

Why did they stop using Roman tactics?

Keeping the loyalty of the legions was a big problem. As the Roman Empire declined, so did the financial and organisational resources of Western Europe. Up until the 15th century, nobody had the resources to maintain a force like the Roman legions.

Why did no one copy the Roman army?

Roman law specified that only the elected magistrates (consuls and praetors) could hold imperium within Italy. Any promagistrate who entered Italy at the head of his troops forfeited his imperium and was therefore no longer legally allowed to command troops.

Who was the strongest Roman soldier?

Also reported in Livy, the Battle of Caudine Forks was a most humiliating defeat. The Roman consuls Veturius Calvinus and Postumius Albinus decided to invade Samnium in 321 BCE, but they planned poorly, choosing the wrong route.

More Answers On Could A Roman Legion Defeat A Medieval Army

Could a Roman legion defeat a medieval army? – Quora

Firstly, by medieval army, Im going to assume you mean peak medieval, as in the 14th and 15th centuries. The Roman legion would be bowled over, quite literally. The standard legion is largely equipped for close range infantry tactics. They did not carry pikes, and did not have much in the way of ranged weapons.

Could a Roman legion defeat a medieval army? – World History

Could a Roman legion defeat a medieval army? A Medieval army should defeat a Roman army all things being equal. It would be like a well drilled WW1 army unit meeting a regular WW2 one. The WW2 guys would have similar weapon systems. Tanks, machine guns, artillery, aircraft etc.

Could a Roman legion defeat a medieval army? – The Roman Empire

A Medieval army should defeat a Roman army all things being equal. It would be like a well drilled WW1 army unit meeting a regular WW2 one. The WW2 guys would have similar weapon systems. Tanks, machine guns, artillery, aircraft etc. But the WW2 guys would just have a massive edge in both weapons systems and infantry tactics, warfare of …

Could the Roman Army beat a medieval army? – Quora

Yes, the Romans could beat a medieval Western European army. They were better at using field fortifications and better at playing an aggressive role as infantry. Their cavalry were not as good in close combat.

Could a Roman legion defeat a medieval army? – The Roman Empire

Skip to content. Skip to search

How well would a Roman army do against selected medieval armies?

I would guess that 1st century AD Roman armies would easily defeat any medieval army thanks to their superiority in doctrine, organization and logistics. I would think that any armed forces from 3000 BC to 1500 AD would be significantly inferior to the legions.

Roman legion – Wikipedia

The Roman legion ( Latin: legiō, [ˈɫɛɡioː]) was the largest military unit of the Roman army, composed of 5,200 infantry and 300 equites (cavalry) in the period of the Roman Republic (509 BC-27 BC) and of 5,600 infantry and 200 auxilia in the period of the Roman Empire (27 BC – AD 1453)

Roman military decorations and punishments – Wikipedia

Grass crown – (Latin: corona obsidionalis or corona graminea), was the highest and rarest of all military decorations.It was presented only to a general, commander, or officer whose actions saved the legion or the entire army. Civic crown – (Latin: corona civica), was a chaplet of common oak leaves woven to form a crown.During the Roman Republic, and the subsequent Principate, it was …

The Roman Legions: The Organized Military Force Of The Roman Empire

The Worst Defeat in the History of the Legions Also known as the Varian Disaster, the Battle of the Teutoburg Forest was an enormous loss for Augustus Germanicus and, by extension, the Roman Empire. It occurred in 9 AD, when the Roman general Publius Quinctillius Varus was foolishly led into an ambush by his own officer, Arminius.

Could a Single Marine Unit Destroy the Roman Empire?

The Roman legions and Marines are both highly trained with a clear unit structure and hierarchy of command. They emphasize aggression, dominating the opponent, unit cohesion, and being flexible on …

Dan Carlin claims that “You could take the roman army at it’s height in …

the romans would have had so many advantages working in their favor before they even arrived at the battlefield that the medievals would have a lot to overcome (start with numbers…the romans, in part due to superior logistics and organization, would almost certainly badly outnumber the medievals…rarely were armies of more than 12,000-15,000 …

Roman Army – Recruitment, Legions, Siege Warfare & More

In war, a soldier who violated or failed to carry out the general’s order could be punished by death, even if the action had been advantageous to the army. Sources Polybius (c. 203-120 B.C.) on the Roman Military “Training Soldiers for the Roman Legion,” by S. E. Stout. “The Classical Journal”, Vol. 16, No. 7. (Apr., 1921), pp. 423-431.

Roman army – Wikipedia

The Roman army (Latin: exercitus Romanus) was the armed forces deployed by the Romans throughout the duration of Ancient Rome, from the Roman Kingdom (to c. 500 BC) to the Roman Republic (500-31 BC) and the Roman Empire (31 BC-395 AD), and its medieval continuation, the Eastern Roman Empire (historiographically known as the Byzantine Empire).It is thus a term that may span approximately …

Roman Legion: Tactics, Armor & Weapons | Study.com

The default military formation for a legion involved having the cavalry ride along the front and side flanks of the rest of the legion. This was followed by two rows of five cohorts of heavy …

List of Roman legions – Wikipedia

Main article: Late Roman army Shield pattern of the palatina legion of the Ioviani seniores, according to the Notitia Dignitatum. Diocletian reorganized the Roman army, in order to better counter the threat of the Germanic peoples of northern Europe as well as that of the Persians from the East. The army was formed by border and field units.

Top 10 Roman Legion – HistoryTen

This legion campaigned and fought against numerous army including the Sextus Pompeius and Mark Antony. However, its first battle was in Perusia in 41 BC against Mark Antony and Cleopatra. This battle brought an end to Antony and Cleopatra’s plan to claim Rome’s empire by defeating their army in the Battle of Actium on the 2nd of September, 31 BC.

tactics – The legion | Britannica

Though its exact origins are unknown, the Roman legion seems to have developed from the phalanx. In fact, it was a collection of small, well-integrated, well-coordinated phalanxes arrayed in checkerboard formation and operating as a team. Hellenistic heavy infantry relied on the pike almost exclusively; the legion, by contrast, possessed both shock and firepower—the former in the form of the …

Barbarians at the Gate – The Last Battles of the Roman Army …

(Image source: WikiCommons) Orleans 463. Following the sack of Rome by the Vandals in 455, the new Roman emperor Avitus sought to stave off total defeat by opening a dialogue with the Western Empire’s other historic foe, the Visigoths.It was a controversial policy that was condemned by an ambitious Roman warlord by the name of Majorian.In 457, the anti-Visigoth general deposed Avitus and …

The Roman Army Overview | The Roman Empire

At the outset of the Second Punic War, the historian Polybius tells us in his formula togatorum, Rome possessed the largest and finest army of the Mediterranean. Six legions made up of 32’000 men and 1600 cavalry, together with 30’000 allied infantry and 2’000 allied cavalry. And this was merely the standing army.

Roman Army: Tactics, Organization, and Command Structure

The ancient Roman army was known for its sheer discipline and incredible organizational depth. Pertaining to the latter ‘quality’, an animated short video by Blair Harrower aptly demonstrates how the Romans organized their army down to the last details when it came to troop-types, corresponding officers, and their formations, thus alluding to an impressive tactical scope that was matched …

Rome vs Medieval armies – Total War Forums

Medieval armies definitely win in the ranged game, as many have said. An array of Crossbows, longbows and modern artillery could destroy a Roman army, puncturing their Testudos. Fast like the wind, Silent like a forest, Intrusive like the fire, Immobile like a mountain, Under heaven and earth, I alone am feared.

military – How quickly could the Roman legions march? How did it …

The ‘Raid March’ practised by the French Foreign Legion requires a march of 75 miles in 3 days in full combat gear carrying rifle and 70 pounds of gear. A Full Pace march for a Roman Legionary in basic training required a march in daylight hours of 22 miles. Clearly it is entirely possible a Roman Legion could march 20-30 miles per day if …

How fast would a Modern military beat a military from Ancient times

That is, 30 modern soldiers are more than a match for 4,800 Roman soldiers. A modern brigade can have anywhere between 3,000 and 5,000 soldiers as well, so doing the math (and not counting vehicles and heavy weapons which they would have in large quantities) a modern brigade is far stronger than a hundred Roman legions.

The Worst Defeat Of the Roman Armies, Ever! – WAR HISTORY ONLINE

Nov 15, 2015 William Mclaughlin, Guest Author. The Battle of Teutoburg Forest was one of the worst defeats suffered by the Roman army in its entire existence not in terms of men lost, though many were, but in terms of setting limits to Roman expansion and dispelling the reputation of the power of the Roman army.

Roman legion – Wikipedia

The Roman legion ( Latin: legiō, [ˈɫɛɡioː]) was the largest military unit of the Roman army, composed of 5,200 infantry and 300 equites (cavalry) in the period of the Roman Republic (509 BC-27 BC) and of 5,600 infantry and 200 auxilia in the period of the Roman Empire (27 BC – AD 1453)

Did The Spartans Beat The Romans? [Comprehensive Answer]

Could the Roman army beat a medieval army? Ultimately, the Romans would almost certainly win a hand-to-hand, face-to-face fight, but Medieval warfare no longer revolved around that, and the heavy Knights and Longbowmen would likely make short work of the Legions before they could close for battle. Would a Spartan beat a Viking? Marx: Put it simply, Spartans fought a lot longer than the Vikings …

The Roman Legions: The Organized Military Force Of The Roman Empire

The Roman Legions: The Organized Military Force Of The Roman Empire. Tin tức Romanos IV Diogenes: An Ambitious Byzantine Emperor Unjustly Deposed? Tin tức Swiss Metal Detectorist Finds 1,290 4th Century Roman Coins! Tin tức . The Roman Legions: The Organized Military Force Of The Roman Empire. Tin tức. Aquincum: Exploring the Ancient Roman City Under Modern-day Budapest. Tin tức …

Roman Army – Recruitment, Legions, Siege Warfare & More

The Roman army under Augustus consisted of 25 legions (according to Tacitus). Each legion consisted of about 6,000 men and a large number of auxiliaries. Augustus increased the time of service from six to 20 years for legionaries. Auxiliaries (non-citizen natives) enlisted for 25 years. A

How Many U.S. Marines Could Bring Down the Roman Empire?

If each individual shot was a kill shot, and 1500 of the 2200 Marines were used, (considering others are deployed with artillery and armour), they would kill 315,000 Roman Soldiers. Thus said, it is highly unlikely each shot would be a kill shot. If used in quick, and decisive blows, the Marines could defeat the entire Roman Army. This would be …

Roman military decorations and punishments – Wikipedia

Grass crown – (Latin: corona obsidionalis or corona graminea), was the highest and rarest of all military decorations.It was presented only to a general, commander, or officer whose actions saved the legion or the entire army. Civic crown – (Latin: corona civica), was a chaplet of common oak leaves woven to form a crown.During the Roman Republic, and the subsequent Principate, it was …

Resource

https://www.quora.com/Could-a-Roman-legion-defeat-a-medieval-army?share=1
https://worldhistory.quora.com/Could-a-Roman-legion-defeat-a-medieval-army?share=1
https://theromanempire.quora.com/Could-a-Roman-legion-defeat-a-medieval-army-3?share=1
https://www.quora.com/Could-the-Roman-Army-beat-a-medieval-army?share=1
https://theromanempire.quora.com/Could-a-Roman-legion-defeat-a-medieval-army-1?share=1
https://historum.com/threads/how-well-would-a-roman-army-do-against-selected-medieval-armies.97218/
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roman_Legion
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roman_military_decorations_and_punishments
https://www.ancient-origins.net/history-ancient-traditions/roman-legions-0014214
https://www.popularmechanics.com/military/a7341/rome-sweet-rome-could-a-single-marine-unit-destroy-the-roman-empire/
https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/18u20t/dan_carlin_claims_that_you_could_take_the_roman/
https://www.thoughtco.com/roman-army-of-the-roman-republic-120904
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roman_army
https://study.com/academy/lesson/roman-legion-tactics-armor-weapons.html
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Roman_legions
https://historyten.com/roman/roman-legion/
https://www.britannica.com/topic/tactics/The-legion
https://militaryhistorynow.com/2018/10/28/going-out-with-a-bang-the-last-battles-of-the-roman-army/
https://roman-empire.net/army/army-overview/
https://www.realmofhistory.com/2019/12/19/roman-army-tactics-organization-command/
https://forums.totalwar.com/discussion/108090/rome-vs-medieval-armies
https://history.stackexchange.com/questions/8226/how-quickly-could-the-roman-legions-march-how-did-it-compare-to-their-cavalry
https://historum.com/threads/how-fast-would-a-modern-military-beat-a-military-from-ancient-times.43183/page-15
https://www.warhistoryonline.com/featured/disaster-teutoburg-forest-worst-defeat-roman-armies-ever.html
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roman_Legion
https://candana.mymom.info/did/did-the-spartans-beat-the-romans.php
https://news.binodon24live.com/the-roman-legions-the-organized-military-force-of-the-roman-empire/
https://www.thoughtco.com/roman-army-of-the-roman-republic-120904
https://www.openculture.com/2011/11/how_many_us_marines_could_bring_down_the_roman_empire.html
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roman_military_decorations_and_punishments